Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2026
Dr. Brenneman is an excellent physician. He is very professional, knowledgeable and really listens. I’ve messaged him several times and he promptly responds. Dr. Brenneman has a kind, gentle manner. I appreciate his expertise and explanations of images and other test results. I would highly recommend him if you have any issues with your knees.
Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2026
So pleased with Dr. Brenneman. Great communication. Answers all questions. Never feel rushed and he has great bedside manner. Had left hip replaced in November and having right replaced this month. Wouldn’t want any other surgeon. Aldo must give a shout out to Courtney. She is wonderful.
Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2025
I have been very pleased with both his manner and professionalism. He listens well and gives wise counsel. He replaced my hip two summers ago and probably do my knee next year. My daughter, who Doctor of Nurse Practitioner thought that he was great.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2025
This was a post-op visit after having a TKR done in September. Dr. Brenneman spends the time to answer all your questions and doesn’t rush through your appointment. I really feel that he cares about his patients.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2025
Dr Brenneman has been my surgeon for 6 years I needed knee replacements Went through the injections first It came time for the surgery He is absolutely one of the best person and fortunately a surgeon His mannerisms are on top, his personality, his approach about what needs to be done and how, his whole persona is nothing but extraordinary Thanks to Dr Brenneman my knees are better than ever!!!
Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2025
I took my 97 year old mother to Dr Brennaman to treat her arthritic knees. He was very kind and gave her a cortisone injection. My mother likes how he treats her and always says, “ I like that doctor so much. He’s so nice.”
rater8 Verified Patient
Oct-2025
He’s the nicest doctor. He talks to you, he listens to you, he’ll ask if you have any questions for him. I would recommend him to anybody a friend of mine gave me his name. She was very pleased with him and how he helped her so much I would give him a 10 star.rater8 Verified Patient
Sep-2025
Dr. Brenneman is an extremely kind, compassionate surgeon. Very happy I chose him. My TKR could not have gone any better. Dr. Brenneman addressed all my concerns and anxieties and explained everything that was going to happen before being taken to the OR. Would highly recommend him and OAL!Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2025
Entire staff was caring and went out of their way to get me what I needed. Dr. Brenneman demonstrated confidence in his treatment of me as an individual. I appreciated being given options. I feel good about a follow up meeting with him.Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2025
The whole Office OAL in Lebanon is such a wonderful place to visit get services treatment and just have wonderful knowledge that they will give you when you ask. The front desk was awesome. His assistant was awesome and Dr. Brennerman is an awesome man he talk to you not at you. He asked questions. He listened to everything I would say suggestions different treatments that are available, and a good plan to work with. I have been a patient of OAL Lebanon for more than 8 years so they have to be good or I wouldn’t be going there still after 8 yearsPatient Submitted Review
Sep-2025
Absolutely phenomenal! I highly recommend Dr. Brenneman to anyone I know is going through knee and/or hip pain! He always takes time to explain everything and really gets to know his patients needs! I won't ever go to anyone else!Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2025
Very caring doctor and patience as I am a senior citizen. Explaining everything in full that I can understand. Also very good at giving a none-painful shot or two or three! In treatment now and glad I am in his care!Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2025
Dr. Brenneman was patient answering all my questions in a way that made me feel very comfortable. My wife and I both had questions, probably more than most, but we left feeling confident. When my knees both need replacement it will be with Dr. Brenneman.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2025
Dr. Brenneman, is an exceptional doctor and very knowledgeable and professional . He was very attentive; he listened to all my problems and provided me with explanations for every question. I appreciated his willingness to know exactly what was my problem. I was very pleased with my visit.rater8 Verified Patient
Aug-2025
Dr Brenneman is exceptional He is very informative and explains everything and always answers your questions He did my both knee replacements and now treating my hip issues I would recommend Dr Brenneman to anyone who asks me who a good ortho surgeon for knees n hips! A exceptional surgeon and person!!Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2025
Dr Brenneman is an exceptional surgeon He has been taking care of me for 6 years He did my surgery for both knee replacements and it went absolutely great He is now treating me for the issue with my hips Always is informative and explains everything to you and answers all questions you have Would recommend him to anyone who asked me if I knew a good surgeon for knees or hips I would never think twice!!rater8 Verified Patient
Jul-2025
He is a rock star. If you kneed the best in orthopaedic care, look no further. He is hip as well as head and shoulders above the rest. He possesses the wisdom of a much older man. He is clearly concerned with treating a human patient, not just approaching treatment like an auto mechanic.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2025
Dr Brenneman was able to quickly diagnose my condition and provide me with a solution. I walked into his office with significant pain, and left feeling much better and with a plan eradicate the pain completely.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2025
Check-in was simple and quick. Wait time was minimal. My initial interface about the current problem went smoothly, The X-Ray Tech was personable and efficient. Dr. Brenneman was prepared when he saw me, He know my history and my current problem. He is a very nice person, an excellent diagnostician, and a superb surgeon. He has operated on me twice for other joint replacements and I won't settle for anyone else!Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2025
June 25th will be total replacement of my right knee. I feel confident this surgery will turn out like my left knee total replacement which happened six years ago by Dr. Rodney Brenneman. Both knees had tremendous pain with days that couldn’t even walk before operation. After 1st operation I had zero pain and physical therapy was a breeze. I’m hoping for same results on my right knee. Dr Brenneman is very qualified and cares about each individual like we were family. Thank you Dr Rodney Brenneman.rater8 Verified Patient
Jun-2025
Dr. Brenneman is a very good doctor and surgeon. He listens to you and answers all of your questions. I had knee surgery and now I need my other knee done. I will be going back to him. Thank you Dr. Brenneman.....Patient Submitted Review
May-2025
I had pain so bad in my knees from my dog pulling me. Saw Dr Brenneman he was so gentle and kind. He gave me 2 shots in my knees. I haven’t had any problems in 2 years. I would recommend him to anyone he was so kind.Patient Submitted Review
May-2025
I just had an 8 week check-in for my left knee replacement. (Right knee was last year!) If I had a third knee, I’d trust no one other than Dr. Brenneman. He’s personable - listens, explains, and encourages. I’m thankful I found him.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2025
Everyone was great! Staff, nurses, PAs and Dr. Brenneman! They took the best possible care of me. I’d recommend highly for any Ortho issues! My wife (recently) and Daughter (last year) also had excellent care!Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2025
I was checked in quickly and only had a short wait before being seen. The nurse was very thorough and Dr. Brennaman saw me right after that. He listened carefully and gave options for treatment. He explained what was going on in a way that was very understandable. Good visit.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2025
Dr. Brenneman is #1 in my book. He explains everything to you to understand what can help your issue. I had Left total knee replacement last year March. Went very well. Just had my 1 year follow up and all is good. I am happy and will always recommend Dr. Brenneman and his staff.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2025
Dr. Brenneman has a calm manner when discussing orthopedic issues. He showed my xray on the computer screen to point out the problem area. Discussed treatment options and answered my questions. Discussed treatment plans in easily understood terms.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2024
During our conversation today I found Dr Brenneman to be interested in what I had to say, respectful of my decision and very pleasant. He offered me the opportunity to revisit my decision if I chose to do so at a later date, or not. I left feeling validated and pleased with our dialogue. I highly recommend him as a surgeon, and his “bedside” manner is top notch.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2024
I had an excellent experience having my left knee replaced by Dr. Brenneman. After speaking with other Doctors I chose Dr. Brenneman.He listened to my concerns offered a solution to my problems. I would not hesitate to recommend him. My surgery was on SEPTEMBER 23, 2024 , I was walking on the new knee on the same day with a walker. After 19 days I no longer need a cane to walk.Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2024
Dr. Brenneman has always been number 1in my book. We crossed paths a few years back when I needed total shoulder replacement. He’s talented , experienced, respected by his colleagues and makes sure you understand all the options available to you. Dr. Brenneman makes you feel relaxed when it comes to the procedure he will be doing. He also has a team that works diligently to get all the necessary correspondence mailed to you as quickly as possible. They keep you informed up to the day of your scheduled surgery and after. FYI The good doctor wears the most fascinating and $$$$ boots.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2024
Dr. Brenneman was professional, sensitive to my wife's and my questions and concerns. He took sufficient time to make sure we understood and agreed with the course of treatment we determined. He continues to be a caring professional.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2024
Dr. Brenneman is great at listening to my concerns and walking me through options. He doesn’t push an agenda, and he’s direct about treatment options. He also has a gentle touch which makes needles in the knees much easier to handle.rater8 Verified Patient
Jul-2024
Dr Brenneman is always pleasant And listens attentively to any concerns He then gives you a clear solution to move forward. He cares and shows That by helping come to a good outcome for each situation.Patient Submitted Review
May-2024
The staff at Orthopedic Surgery is always courteous, and the care I received during my recent visit was friendly and completely adequate. Dr. Brenneman answered my questions without making me feel pressured.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2024
The staff is very supportive and kind. Dr Brenneman is SO knowledgeable. I appreciated that he asked me how I would feel about the treatment he recommended. And then asked about the timing of said treatment. I would highly recommend him as your Doctor.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2024
Dr. Brenneman was caring and was concerned about me as the patient. He asked questions, asked about my concerns, and listened. He explained how he was going to treat the condition. He also advised what to look for in the future. His team worked very well together. Everyone explained their part of the patient care. I felt well taken care of and was impressed with everyone. Thank you to Dr. Brenneman.rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2024
I found Dr. Brenneman to be a very caring doctor. He took the time to explain what was happening and what could be done for treatment. He also advised what to look for in the future. He is very personable and treats his patients with respect and concern for their overall well being.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2024
Dr. Brenneman and his whole staff were kind, efficient and knowledgeable about my condition. I especially appreciated his approach to letting me decide how to proceed with treatment leading up to eventual knee replacement.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2024
I had excellent results from my knee replacement. Ahead of time Dr. Brenneman explained everything very thoroughly. He was easy to talk to, and took time for questions. His staff members were also pleasant and easy to work with. I highly recommend Dr. Brenneman.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2024
Dr Brenneman listened to all my concerns and answered all of my questions. It felt like he had all the time in the world to talk...I never felt rushed. He explains things in ways that are easy to understand...not using huge medical terms without explaining them. Have recommended him to others and will continue to do so!!Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2024
My Dr. Is always professional, good natured, explains in detail what I need to know. Answers any questions I my have that I don't understand just reading material. Highly recommend Dr. Brenneman and the whole Orthopedic Associates of Lancaster. Thank you for such great care.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2024
He is always very helpful. I have had both hips done under his care with no complaints. .up an running in about a month. Works very well with patients. I trust him, I have more surgeries to go and they will be done by him, I have absolute confidence in him.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2024
I had my first visit with Dr. Brenneman recently. He took his time to answer any questions and explained my options. I appreciated the care I received from him and would highly recommend him to anyone looking for an orthopedic doctor.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
I was there for a pre-operative visit to talk about the procedure for my knee. It went well and Dr. Brenneman was pleasant as usual. The other staff were very friendly and helpful. Xray tech was also friendly.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
Dr. Brenneman diagnosed my problem easily from the x-rays. He carefully explained my options and explained why knee replacement would be impossible now because of my diabetes condition. Together we determined a plan of action and after only one day, my knee feels great.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
This was a follow up visit a year after my knee replacement surgery. My knee is doing just fine. Thus, I can say he did good work, he listened to me, and he provided me with answers to my questions, all in a friendly manner. Five stars for Dr. Brenneman!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
I can’t say enough about how wonderful doctor Brennneman is. He friendly, knowledgeable, caring. When explaining the diagnosis he tells you in terms you can understand without making you feel belittled. I switched orthopedic doctors to be with him. He is the best Orthopedic doctor I’ve had.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2023
From diagnosis through surgery and post operative care I felt confident with the care I received from Dr. Brenneman and the entire OAL team. Everything was thoroughly explained and any concerns were addressed promptly. I wholeheartedly recommend Dr. Brenneman and OAL.rater8 Verified Patient
Nov-2023
I have total confidence in the care I receive from Dr. Brenneman. He is very thorough and hasn't given up tryimg to figure out what is wrong with my knee. He is also pleasant to deal with as well. A nice plus.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2023
I just had my pre surgery apt with Dr Brenneman and he explained Everything thoroughly. He has a gift To calm you and put yr mind to rest In addition to being the best surgeon You could have to replace yr knee Yr very blessed if you seek his help.rater8 Verified Patient
Sep-2023
He is professional and friendly in his career. He's done excellent surgery with both hip replacements and so happy to be out of pain. Anxious to get back to normal routine and be able to bike again. Highly recommend to anyone who's in need of relief. God bless him.🙏Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2023
Dr. Brenneman did my total knee replacement surgery on June 27th and everything went very well. Everything with the process was well organized, excellent communication with both the pre and postoperative instructions. Dr. Brenneman and his team provided excellent care and I would highly recommend him to anyone considering knee replacement surgery.Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2023
Dr. Brenneman is truly focused on his patient’s well being in every sense. He made himself available to see me even though he was not scheduled to be on site. The entire OAL team is professional and caring.Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2023
Dr. Brenneman is truly a compassionate doctor with a great bedside manner. He explains everything you need to know about the procedure and the medications involved. He answers any and all questions willingly. I followed all of his instructions to the letter, especially the pre-op and post-op PT and had a brilliant result with my total knee replacement.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2023
I saw Dr. Brenneman for a pre surgery visit. He explained everything to me about the surgery, and what I should expect afterwards. He took the time to answer any questions I had. I felt very confident in him, had no more questions and was ready to move forward with the procedure. He is very knowledgeable, professional and friendly.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2023
Everyone was so professional and so very kind! They took me in right away when I did not have an appt. I tore my meniscus and was in a lot of pain and came right to them. I highly recommend this place!Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2023
Dr. Brenneman explains things clearly and simply -- he replaced a right hip the same day I went to the hospital and I have had no pain immediately after the operation and no pain any time since. He did an excellent job and he is a really nice guy who cares.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2023
Dr. Brenneman is very professional and thorough, and he listens carefully to concerns and problems. When I was in a lot of discomfort the day after my surgery, Dr. Brenneman went an extra mile to make time to see me and help to assure me that everything was actually as expected, and to give me information to cope with pain. I have already recommended him to a friend who is in need of surgery similar to mine.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
Dr Brenneman provides a satisfying medical experience. I have been treated by him for the past 6 years and he is always professional giving me my treatment options. And allowing me to weight and choose my own path. I have not felt rushed or ignored.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
I am preparing for total knee replacement surgery with Dr. Brenneman. The whole process has been very organized, staff have been very helpful and friendly and Dr. Brenneman has been great to work with.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
I was having knee issues for years. He tried different things to help me but nothing was working. So we decided on the replacement. After having problems with my blood pressure & broken humorous it finally happened I am very thankful for Dr. Brenneman. I had it done May 12 ,2023. I already feel a big difference. He has a great bed side manner. He never gave up on me He kept me on his schedule. I will be ever grateful.rater8 Verified Patient
May-2023
Known Dr B for over two years, his attendance for my issues was superb, educational, very informative for me, never being afflicted by 3 surgeries at one time, he took great care of me and my emotional acceptance of needing new parts. This week was my yearly checkup and I'm still getting great care, THANKS TO DR.Brater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2023
Dr. Brenneman is very thoughtful with his approach with my elderly mother. His communication is collaborative and respectful. With mom’s independence waning as she ages, this kind of communication and giving her choices and an opportunity to add commentary is really appreciated.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2023
Dr. Brennerman and his team at OAL are very caring, professional and competent in all aspects before during and after the surgery. Dr. Brenneman performed a complete hip replacement on my other hip 5 years go and i chose him for this hip with no hesitation.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2023
Dr. Brenneman cleaned out an infection in my hip. It was the 2nd time it needed cleaned out. I found him to be very compassionate, professional and he explained things to my husband and I and took the time to make sure we understood and answered all of out questions. I highly recommend Dr. Brenneman.rater8 Verified Patient
Mar-2023
I have been a patient of this doctor for several years. He is the best of the best. Caring is near the top of his list. I think he puts his patients feelings above his own. Three surgeries, and I have had NO hesitations. Dr. Brenneman can be put at the very top of the treasured, trusted and recommended Orthopedic Surgeons in Lancaster County and beyond.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2023
Very happy with Dr. Brenneman's work. Great experience start to finish. Everyone was polite, professional and caring. Recovering nicely. Knee replacement went well and I was very surprised to walk out in just a few hours. Thank you for everything!Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2023
The staff are always helpful at Orthopedic Associates. I did not have a long wait to see Dr. Brenneman. Dr. Brenneman takes time with his patients, explains how the healing process is going and answers all questions. I am very pleased with how professional and caring everyone in his group treats patients.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2023
Dr Brenneman is very very very very best knee doctor and surgeon around. I get my shots only from him and he hit the right sweet spot to make them feel all so good. My sister goes to him now an she got both total knee replacement and she LOVES her knees now she is able to get up and move all so much better to walk again. I tell people all the time about him. HE THE BEST AROUND TRY HIMPatient Submitted Review
Jan-2023
From the first woman who took my call for an appointment to my visit with Dr. Brenneman yesterday, I cannot say enough positive words about OAL. Thank God I switched to this group! I look forward to my upcoming surgery and being in the care of Dr. Brenneman for many years. I can’t say enough about his calmness, attentiveness, knowledge and overall demeanor.rater8 Verified Patient
Jan-2023
Doctor Brennemans matter of fact, to the point, bedside manner was refreshing. Finally a doctor who speaks to you in plain english that you don’t need a medical degree to follow along. He did not seemed rushed for time or give you the impression that his time was more important than yours. Earned my respect immediately.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2022
Dr Brenneman, as well as the support staff, were all very personable, informative and took time to deal with any questions I had. Dr Brenneman took more than adequate time to review x-rays taken and explain his diagnosis and game plan.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2022
Dr Brennaman has always treated my family great. He is attentive & answers everything asked. He has done 4 joint replacements on myself and the care I received was amazing! He’s kind and considerate & I have always felt he truly listens & cares for me. I recommend him to everyone for any Orthopedic needs. In my experience, his bedside manner is exemplary, I’ve never felt rushed in an appointment. He’s the best! I’d give him 10 stars if possible.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2022
After going to so many doctors in the last 6 years for my osprosis arthritis I finally have a doctor who wants to listen to me and finally help me with a knee replacement surgery and everyone there is so nice 🙂 So thank uPatient Submitted Review
Sep-2022
I have been seeing doctor Brenneman for approximately 2 years and he has always been patient and kind. I appreciate his understanding of my many questions and 'need to know' personality...even when I show up with double-blind studies in hand! His recommendations have always been just what I needed.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2021
I already have. Dr. Brenneman replaced my knee 5 weeks ago and the pain I was experiencing prior to surgery is gone. Both Dr. B and Hope have been wonderful through the entire replacement. Prepared me well and had me do PT prior to the surgery which has helped me bounce back quickly following surgery. Loved their new surgical center and was able to go home immediately following surgery. Highly recommend!Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2020
My right knee was clicking and I couldn't put my leg flat on a surface. Dr. Brenneman repaired the knee that was riddled with arthritis; while he had the leg open, he worked to loosen the musculature around the knee. Now my knee works properly and I can press it flat. I can't say enough good about Dr. Brenneman! Besides his being an outstanding surgeon, he is a very nice person with great interpersonal skills.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2020
Dr. Brenneman was very attentive to our questions and thorough in his explanations. He is very caring and personal in his approach to his patients. We couldn't have been more pleased with him for my hip replacement surgery!Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2017
I am a senior citizen, tore my rotator cuff and Dr. Brenneman repaired it. The surgery went very well. I had expected a painful recovery as I have friends who had the same procedure done many years ago. My recovery was pain free! I feel that the procedures that Dr. Brennenan used are the prime reasons for my smooth recovery.Read more
Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2026
I was very impressed with Dr. Brenneman 's knowledge and caring demeanor. He has all the answers and took interest in my needs. Having been a patient @ another orthopedic provider over 15+ years, I welcomed the positive attitude of the "good doctor" and all of the staff @ OAL. Thank you and I hope to continue our relationship for the next 15+ years!