Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2026
Dr. Carrol is a phenomenal physician. He takes his time with his patients, gives exceptional care, and explains this thoroughly. My son has been his patient for over a year now, and we have been beyond pleased with the level of care that he has received.
Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2026
Dr Carroll was professional, friendly, knowledgeable and a great listener. He laid out a logical and reasonable plan of care on my initial visit that I was very happy with. I will definitely return for follow up care and would recommend him to anyone needing his expertise. Kudos.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2026
Dr Carroll is wonderful. He really took the time to explain everything to us and make my daughter comfortable during her manual exam. I'm confident with his level of experience and down-to-earth approach.
Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2026
I was extremely happy with Dr. Carroll. This was his third time operating on me and I would recommend him to anyone that needs an Orthopedic surgeon. He is kind, patient, compassionate and very thorough. He is the BEST! Plus, his staff is amazing! Ashley and Jen go above and beyond!Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2025
I have been seeing Dr. Carroll for almost 30 years. That in itself should tell you how amazing he is, not only as a doctor, but as a person. He always asks how my family and I are doing, which shows he really cares. He pays attention to what I have to say and answers my questions in a way I understand. I give him a 5 star recommendation and would encourage others to see him if they need an Orthopedist.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2025
Dr Carroll is kind, patient, and spent time making sure I understood everything about my surgery. Staff is thorough and kind also. Surgery center staff are all kind and caring and thorough. Can’t say enough about everyone!Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2025
Very thoughtful and thoroughly explained diagnosis and treatment plan. Appreciated the integrity of the whole experience with OAL; from urgent care to scheduling, to MRI, to follow-up appointment and now grateful for the treatment plan going forward. Thank you.
rater8 Verified Patient
Aug-2025
He is how all Dr.'s should be...he listens to u.Then he explains everything clearly to u.He makes u feel comfortable,gets u to smile,when ur in pain.I would tell anyone,who would need to see an Orthopaedic Dr.,to see Dr.CarrollPatient Submitted Review
Aug-2025
I have been seeing Dr. Carroll for almost 30 years. He has always had my best interest in mind. He's always kind and really listens to my concerns. I would highly recommend him to anyone that needs orthopedic care.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2025
Dr Carroll is great! He is always on the point with his diagnose of the issue and gives you all of your options and is willing to walk through them and figure out what works for you. We trusted him in treating our D1 athlete as she was finishing up her Senior year.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2025
Dr. Carroll, was really great! I went to see him regarding a pre-existing knee injury. I wanted to build a rapport with him as I will need some sort of replacement in the coming years. He explained my situation and where I was at very clearly. We went over my current X-rays and he explained what we were looking at in detail. I feel really good moving forward should I need a knee replacement. Dr. Carroll is now my go to physician for my knee issues.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2025
Dr. Carroll is really a special physician, he has a great bedside manner and he provides in depth information to help you understand the negatives and positives of your issues, which is comforting in theses days where some physicians have fallen on the wayside. He helps you understand in a caring and kind way. Thank goodness for physicians like him!
Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2025
Dr Carroll was very kind, professional and took time to explain my injury in a way I could understand. Gave me helpful suggestions to manage pain moving forward and encouraged to call if I need another appt in the future. Highly recommend!Patient Submitted Review
May-2025
He was very professional and thorough. Was also very clear about game plan for medical care moving forward, as well as very attentive to make sure everything was understood and all questions were answered.Patient Submitted Review
May-2025
Dr. Carroll did a wonderful job helping our 10yo Autistic daughter feel comfortable and safe, after breaking her thumb. His bedside manner was great and he was able to explain everything to our daughter in a way she understood - even getting her to laugh and smile during a difficult time!Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2025
Dr Carrol and his assistant are terrific. Always pleasant and put you at ease. Professional yet down to earth. It’s not the best part of your day getting bilateral knee shots , but they make it okay. Thank you.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2025
Very pleased with my appointment with Dr. Carroll. He thoroughly addressed the issues I was having with knee and shoulder pain and made useful recommendations (ice, topical diclofenac, physical therapy) to allow me to continue playing pickleballPatient Submitted Review
Jan-2025
This was my first time seeing Dr Carroll. Who is very approachable and thorough. He has a great bedside manner which is refreshing when visiting a physician these days. Although this is a very busy practice I didn't feel like I was rushed at all. I would definitely recommend seeing this physician.rater8 Verified Patient
Dec-2024
Dr Carroll was excellent with our two year old son. He made him feel comfortable and was very thorough. He was great at explaining his injury and prognosis. Highly recommend Dr Carroll and OAL, the process from check in to check out was smooth and the entire staff was excellent.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2024
I have been seeing Dr.Carroll for several years now and he is always caring, and understanding and helpful in finding ways to manage my knee pain. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a caring, knowledgeable Dr. to help with their Healthcare needs.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2024
Dr. Caroll is extremely intelligent and well informed/up to date on orthopedic issues - especially sports injury related issues. I have had a knee problem that is not a typical knee injury - “I have never seen a knee do that before”. I think his approach is very reasonable and I feel confident with his care. Thank you OAL. And the receptionists are super friendly and demonstrate wonderful patient care. Thank You!Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2024
Dr. Carroll is not only an excellent physician, but he is very caring, he takes the time to listen and then addresses ur concerns, and his staff nurses are considerate and compassionate, i would highly recommend him for all of ur orthopedic needsrater8 Verified Patient
Sep-2024
Dr. Carroll was very attentive to my questions during my second option appointment. He personally met with me and we worked through all options and finally worked through the best option for me and my injury. I highly recommend Dr. Carroll!Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2024
Been going here for years.Receive excellent care.Dr.Paul Carroll is an amazing Dr.He is down to earth,very kind & caring with all of his patients.Even on a scale of 1-10,10 being the highest,he would get 100+++.They do not make Dr.'s like him anymore.God bless him,for all he does.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2024
Very impressed. Walked in without an appointment and was being treated by Dr. carroll in less than 30 minutes. Explained the what's and why's of my problem answered my questions then procedded with the procedure while checking on my comfort several times. Explained follow up care and scheduled follow up appt.. Very impressive very professional a credit to his profession.Seriously. 1st and maybe only time I have responded to a survey.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2024
I have been a patient of Dr. Carroll’s for a decade. Dr. Carroll combines a commitment to always do what’s right for the patient and the ability to communicate clearly about expected outcomes for various modalities. In the “ever less personal” climate of medicine we find ourselves, Dr. Carroll has never lost sight of why chose this field. He loves what he does and the patients he helps. That’s a win in my book.rater8 Verified Patient
Jun-2024
Caring and supportive, kind and compassionate. Dr Carroll always has his patients in his best interest. Feeling comfortable with your surgeon helps ease your mind & With Dr Carroll’s friendly demeanor, confidence & experience, you know you’re in good hands!. A++ Thank youPatient Submitted Review
May-2024
Dr. Carroll is outstanding in every area of his practice. He is a superb surgeon and explains everything very well.....he is also a very nice man with a great sense of humor! I highly recommend Dr. Carroll and his practice. (And his assistant, Ashley is also outstanding!)rater8 Verified Patient
May-2024
This man is a Dr.from the past.One that my Grandmother had,that came out to the house,when u were sick.Very okd-fashioned,but knows all about the new medicine.Is very thorough when explaining everything.Does everything with extreme kindness,caring & love pretaining to the care he gives. Also would like to add,that Ashley who works with him,is awesome too.I love them both!!Patient Submitted Review
May-2024
I have seen Dr.Carroll for many years.He is everything good,u would want & need in a Dr.Kind,caring,he feels like family.Explains things thoroughly everytime.I have sent friends to see & will continue to do so.Patient Submitted Review
May-2024
Took time to listen and then provided excellent explanations of my situation. He gave me options, but let me make decisions. He was not quick to recommend surgery. Very upbeat and reassuring. Highly recommended.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2024
He is such a phenomenal doctor. You never feel rushed, he takes time to answer your questions and make sure you understand and goes out of his way to find the best course of action for you. He works alongside Ashley who comes in with him and puts in his orders and she is absolutely wonderful as well.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
Dr. Carroll is great, he’s very jolly and thorough with the medical plan he gives you. After suffering a torn meniscus I endured with surgery he was able to repair it. Thanks to him and his team and the physical therapist at OAL I’ve had a quick recovery. I’d highly recommend him and AOL! Thank you Dr. Carroll and AOL team!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
Dr. Carroll is an outstanding physician! He listens, is very kind and professional. Like all great physicians, he makes you as if you are his only patient. I highly recommend Dr. Carroll for all your orthopedic concerns!Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2023
I went to OAL for a second opinion for my knee. Dr. Carol was a breath of fresh air to me. He was very thorough took time to listen my questions and took time explain everything about my situation. I felt cared for and listened to. I will definitely use OAL when the need arises. John SPatient Submitted Review
Dec-2023
Dr. Carrol and his staff always make sure that their patients are getting the care they need. They listen and are very attentive to his patients. Cannot ask for a better doctor or physician. I highly recommend Dr. CarrolPatient Submitted Review
Dec-2023
After having a very successful double knee replacement two years ago, I have continued to receive the best of care from Dr. Carroll and his wonderful staff. My experience this last appointment, and every appointment was a good one. My wait time is not usually long and I never feel rushed once I get in the exam room.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2023
I have been a patient of Dr. Carroll's for years. He performed both of my knee replacement surgeries and yesterday I saw him because of having pain in my hips. After reviewing my x-rays he told me I have bursitis in the Bursa sac. He advised me to have PT, ice my hip and use a topical anti-inflammatory gel. I trust him completely. He is personable, caring and explains health issues in a way I can understand. I have recommended him to others going through knee issues.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2023
Dr. Carroll is awesome his staff are very thorough and very professional Dr. Carroll you can tell when you speak with him he cares about his patience and their well-being. I highly recommend Dr. Paul, Carroll and his staff at orthopedic Associates of Lancaster.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2023
Absolutely love Dr. Carrol. He's very kind, patient, will take the time to need to answer your questions. I would absolutely trust him with my friends and family's care. Honestly can't say enough about him, just overall phenomenal.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2023
He is outstanding. Caring and most importantly excellent in his profession. He is truly second to none. Been seeing him for a few years and I have never been disappointed. The BEST by far and believe me, I've tried many.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2023
Dr. Carroll is exceptionally skilled and knowledgeable, extremely compassionate and a patient listener. From his ever-present smile and hearty laugh, it's clear he enjoys helping people. My family and I trust him implicitly.rater8 Verified Patient
Jun-2023
Very knowledgeable as well as a welcoming , kind bedside manner. Never made us feel rushed and always gave us plenty of time for each appt. & Gave us his full attention. His expertise as well as personable made it an excellent experience. His attention to our son’s complex medical ( non orthopedic) was greatly appreciated. Working with Dr Carroll and his staff was an overall excellent experience.Patient Submitted Review
May-2023
I had Dr Carroll years ago for an ACL surgery, l really liked him as a Dr. Years later, when l was having issues with my hip..l asked my family Dr to send me to Dr Carroll. My memory of his care...didn't change. He's a caring Dr. I'll always go to him when needed.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2023
I have so much love and respect for this doctor and his entire staff. Always attentive and in tune. I never questioned his opinions and recommendations! He was part of the miracle team that saved my life. I am eternally grateful to be his patient!!!!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2023
I have had nothing but positive experiences with Dr. Carroll and all the staff at his practice. He takes the time to look me in the eye and talk to me. He isn't typing into a computer during my visit. He hears me. He did a great job with my shoulder and continues to be encouraging during my recovery. In addition, all the staff, including the front desk staff, are kind and helpful. It is refreshing to visit this practice.rater8 Verified Patient
Oct-2022
Love how he listens and explains everything thoroughly. He answered my questions to the absolute best of his ability and made me felt heard. He seemed very compassionate and really made me feel at ease with an upcoming surgery.Read more
Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2026
It was great..staff was easy to work with Dr Carroll is a GOOD doctor. He did my ACL surgery..years ago. I came to see about my left shoulder.. took xray..l got a cortisone shot..set me up for therapy...