Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2025
Dr. McMahon is very concerned about his patients as is his whole staff. They take time to answer my questions. That's very important to me. I trust him and his staffs abilities. They are highly appreciated and recommended. I wouldn't hesitate to use them again
Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2025
Dr mcmath and his team are the most caring people I have ever met in the medical profession. He ( they ) have always answered any and all questions that I had regarding my visit today and upcoming surgery in sept and also my surgery that I had on March 4, th. He ( they ) are never quick to rush out of the room to see additional patients that are waiting, if I have any questions at all. I would highly recommend him to everyone that I meet that needs his medical knowledge and help. I would never trust any other Dr with my physical medical issues or with any that my children may experience. I always walk out of his office with a lot less questions and concerns that I have before I get there! He always puts my mind at ease!
Patient Submitted Review
May-2025
Dr McMath is fabulous - took time to address all of my questions and made me feel so much better about my treatment options. I have been to several Dr’s about my hip issues and no other Dr. offered a comprehensive solution, with patience and understanding of my concerns. He did my R total knee replacement and L knee arthroscopy a few years ago, with absolutely perfect results. I am from Bowling Green and it is absolutely worth the travel time. Highly recommend! Staff member who does his scheduling is great! She is thorough, works with you on preferred follow-up times and is kind.Patient Submitted Review
May-2025
Dr McMath has treated me for knee, shoulder, thumb, and hip issues. Most recently he performed a hip core decompression surgery on me. I had one day of discomfort after surgery and have not had any pain since. I was required to use a walker for 6 weeks to allow for healing. Dr McMath has been exceptional in all the issues I have had over the past 10 years. I can not imagine finding another Orthopedic Surgeon that could take care of all on my " getting old" stuff better that Dr McMath. I am very thankful for him and all the various care givers at OIO..
rater8 Verified Patient
May-2025
Very knowledgeable, personable, and professional. He takes the time to listen to you and answer all your questions. He explains things thoroughly and at a level you can understand. He makes you feel like you matter.rater8 Verified Patient
May-2025
Dr. McMath provided me excellent explanation of what was happening and why. How to approach it and make it so I can function as normal in the future! So happy he was able to see me as a patient !Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2025
I had an amazing visit today at my appt with Dr McMath. He was very thorough , he explained everything I needed to know in terms that I could understand. He answered all my questions and I didn’t feel not feel like he was rushing to get out of my exam room to go see his next patient. The wait time was very minimal and his immediate staff did an awesome job ( as always) to answer questions and explain things to me as well. I would definately give him them a 5 ⭐️ rating. They always make me feel like a part of the family when I have my appts there. There is no other office or Dr that I trust as much as these people . Thanks everyone for the great care that I always get when I am there!!rater8 Verified Patient
Mar-2025
Outstanding care by a very skilled surgeon. I am very pleased with my care by Dr McMath and his staff, by OIS staff, and the anesthesia staff . Very pleased with my blocks by Dr Sheiwiler .rater8 Verified Patient
Mar-2025
The staff and Dr. McMath were very professional and pleasant. I felt comfortable and confident about the appointment and the decisions we made to proceed forward. Thanks for seeing me!rater8 Verified Patient
Feb-2025
Very pleased -Dr McMath is kind, very competent and very professional.. I expected the shot in my shoulder to hurt, but it did not. I am hopeful this will help the pain in my shoulder.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2025
Findlay is very fortunate to have such a compassionate, excellent surgeon in Dr McMath. His PA, Todd, also explains things very thoroughly and is very patient with your questions. My physical therapists, Tonya and Kristin were absolutely the best. I can’t say enough about this awesome team of professionals! Thank you all!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2025
Dr. McMath is excellent. Very knowledgeable, caring, thorough, and professional. I trust his expertise, medical advise and direction. Should I ever need to have surgery , Dr McMath would be who I would entrust my care to. Very very pleased.rater8 Verified Patient
Dec-2024
I cannot be more positive about Dr. McMath. He did TKR two my left knee three years ago and it has been absolutely perfect. Six weeks ago he did another TKR, to my right knee and at this point, it also appears to be healing and performing perfectly.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2024
Dr. McMath & his team are the very best. They are compassionate & listen to what you have to say & help you accordingly. They do their very best to get you back to 100% & back to your life.
Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2024
Just want to say that Dr McMath is very thorough caring and is easy to talk to his Assistant is as well . The medical facility is Nice all the Staff is very Friendly and caring . You’ll not be disappointed all the Drs are Very Good.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2024
Today I had Todd, Dr. McMath's PA. He did a great job, explained what I needed, but Dr. McMath is always great, too. Today, 12/5/24 i had Dr. McMath, and he was great! Explained about the shot, and did a great job with the injection. Both Dr. McMath and Todd are super!!!rater8 Verified Patient
Dec-2024
Very professional and knows what he is doing. Very congenial to talk to and took time to answer all questions that I had. Did an excellent job and has a very good reputationPatient Submitted Review
Nov-2024
Dr McMath was professional, helpful, kind and most importantly provided wonderful medical care. My hip replacement was a success and I am grateful for regaining my mobility and strengthPatient Submitted Review
Oct-2024
Very thorough, gave me answers, suggestions for resolution of my current condition. I was worried & upset when I came but left with a completely different outlook. Thank you Dr. McMath and your friendly staff!rater8 Verified Patient
Sep-2024
Dr McMath has treated many of my patients from my family practice. He is skillful. And my patients have had amazing surgical results. I have had no reservations in recommending local surgical care by him on my patients.rater8 Verified Patient
Sep-2024
Dr Mc Math is a wonderful caring Dr that explains the surgery in a way that’s easy to understand. I am so pleased with my June 11th knee surgery. And looking forward to the upcoming other knee surgery. I have complete confidence it will be just as successful.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2024
The receptionists , nurses and staff are always very welcoming and helpful, especially the person( she was stationed in the middle of the check out desk) was so helpful and concerned. She explained very clearly to me where to get physical therapy in Carey, where I live.rater8 Verified Patient
Aug-2024
Dr. McMath was so kind . I came in really hurting after falling and injuring my shoulder but he relieved my stress after showing me the MRI and that I did not tear my rotator cuff which I was told I had done from another doctor. I am so thankful I saw Dr McMath and he was able to help me with a shot and recommended physical therapy.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2024
Dr McMath replaced my left hip in 2015 and my right in 2017, both are working great no problems.Still working a factory job nine years later.Just went today 8/6/2024 for X-ray and checkup .Everything still were it's supposed to be ,Thank you Dr . McMath! In 2015 I could hardly lift my leg up to get in my truck,both sides are now strong.rater8 Verified Patient
Jul-2024
Thank you You did a great job on my carpal tunnel in my hand feel so much more better and I’m sure that my knee will heal just like that. You did a great job on my incision and yes, I have some pain but I hope that it will get better with as time goes on so I can keep moving.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2024
I am very impressed with OIO. The PT staff is awesome. I met with Dr. Mcmath today and he was very professional and thorough. I know the extent of my physical problem and know the options for treatment.rater8 Verified Patient
Jun-2024
Always caring and gentle with his exams. Genuinely wants to do what is best for each of his patients. Takes times to listen to questions and concerns and answers all questions.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2024
Dr. McMath was so kind and thorough!! I had multiple fractures in my ribs and pelvis. He was very positive with my current recovery process. I highly recommend Dr. McMath as your provider.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2024
Dr. McMath is a very accomplished doctor. He came highly recommended and I always felt safe with him. He is also kind and compassionate. As far as I am concerned, that is also very important to the success of the surgery and a good recovery.rater8 Verified Patient
May-2024
I didn't see Jeffery but the gentleman I saw was great. He explained everything in a way that I could understand what was going on and the steps we could take to get me back to my new normal.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2024
Dr. McMath is the consummate professional. Great explanations and laid out the plan of care succinctly while providing answers to all my questions. I am a physical therapist as well as a patient. I have worked with him for many years and I am used to his high level of expertise.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2024
Dr McMath pretty painlessly injected both of my knees with steroid today. It feels so much better, and the entire appointment took only 25 minutes. What an excellent appointment!rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2024
I truly respect and like Dr. McMath for putting steroids in my legs once a month today I have some relief with my pain in my knees, which I am so grateful for. Don’t think I could’ve handled that much longer without getting some Aro ids in May so thank you Dr. Mc Math for helping me.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2024
Conveniently located near my job. Friendly staff and they were very patient with me as I move sort of slow. Super modern examination equipment. I liked the simple xray machine. The doc assistant Todd was very helpful and nice!Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2024
Even though hospital in another town had taken the xrays and didn't see the problem he and his PA were able to see rhe problem right away. They then sent me to a shoulder specialist and fixed the problem for now. Very satisfied withhimrater8 Verified Patient
Feb-2024
He was very professional at his job, and a very likable and knowledgeable Dr. I was told by friends that he was a great Dr. and I believe my friends were right. I will also tell anyone I know that might be going thru the same thing I am, that Dr. McMath is a great Dr.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2024
Dr. McMath is an example doctor. His bedside manner is excellent, he explains things well, shows empathy, presents options in ways you can understand, empathizes with the patient, and is trustworthy. I do not ever hesitate recommending him.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
Very caring Dr who doesn't jump right into surgery. Will try some conservative options first on my knee and see. I had a total knee on the other side done 3 years ago by him and am doing wonderful with it. Wonderful Dr and office staff!!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
Met with Dr. McMath for review of potentially performing a total replacement of my right knee. He was very personal, relaxed, and unhurried in his explanation of what the X-rays show and, his questioning of my pain levels related to various activities. I left feeling very positive about scheduling the procedure.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2024
He was very reassuring. A great 'bedside manner '. His good reputation as a Doctor was substantiated!! Very warm and caring person. He made me feel less worried about the surgery!!!Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2023
Dr. McMath saw my son the very next day after his injury. He took time to explain in detail the injury, the X-ray,s and the treatment, even drawing diagrams to help us understand. Excellent care..Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2023
Got me in for appt within a couple days for swollen knee. Called me back within a couple minutes & Pa-C, Todd took care of my problem promptly. I've gone here for years & I recommend this practice to everyone I know.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2023
Dr McMath’s staff got me in for an appointment very quickly. I’m grateful for their help. Each person I encountered at the practice was professional, kind and answered my questions. My hip replacement surgery is scheduled and I’m feeling prepared.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2023
Our 1st experience with OIO and Dr. McMath was wonderful. The staff was very helpful and pleasant. We were walk ins and were in and out in no time at all. My son broke his collarbone(1st broken bone) and Dr. McMath was very reassuring! We will definitely be recommending!!Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2023
Dr. McMath is wonderful. His calm spirit puts patients right at ease. He is thorough and careful in his exam and his description of what he’s doing, as well as what he recommends and why. His surgical intervention took care of the repeating problem in Joe’s elbow. I highly recommend Dr McMath at OIO and his medical support team. Each one of them are equally wonderful!!!Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2023
I want to like to thank Dr. Mcmath for the work he did on my hip replacement. I had little pain after the surgery. My progress after a year has been shown and felt better than before the surgery. Thank you!!!Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
I saw Todd Sigler PA-C for my 1 year post-op check on my knee. He went over my x-rays and checked the incision site which is very well healed. We talked about how welI I was doing, and what the future plan was. I came away still confident and happy with the care I have received by Dr. Mc Math and Mr. Siegler. Great care and excellent patient education all the way throughPatient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
This review is for my husband, Gary, who is having knee replacement in August. This preparatory appointment is to get medical clearance from family doctor, cardiologist and dentist, go over concerns and answer questions. Printed information is reviewed. It's an excellent way to get the best results. We were reminded that we could call with questions anytime. We both feel very well prepared for his upcoming surgery.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
Dr. McMath and his staff are the best. They take their time with you not run in and out. Dr. McMath and Todd listens and explain so you understand what is going on. The staff is always friendly especially Libby.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2023
My preliminary office visits have been informative and efficiently performed. Since my last knee surgery from Dr. McMath went well, I look forward to this one with no apprehension or concern.rater8 Verified Patient
May-2023
I so appreciate Dr. McMath. He is obviously a highly successful, sought after surgeon. A very busy doctor. Yet he never appears to be rushed. During appointments he is warm, friendly, takes the time to explain things in a way that is understandable.Patient Submitted Review
May-2023
The staff at Dr Mcmath's office is very friendly and efficient! Every time that I have an appointment there I never wait long. Todd is very knowledgeable and always answer all my questions that I have.rater8 Verified Patient
May-2023
Had replacement hip surgery. Dr McMath extremely competent and professional. PA Todd also extremely competent and professional. All questions answered. This was second surgery with Dr Mc Math, who replaced a shoulder joint three years ago. No issues with either surgery.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2023
Dr McMath is a great doctor & a compliment to his profession. He replaced both of my hips, starting over 14 years ago. NEVER have i had an issue with either one ! He is a very knowledgeable person, and very pleasant to deal with. I always go to him first ,for any orthopedic problems. Everyone in the facility, from the front desk , to checking out , are the friendliest , most helpful people around.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2023
As always your treated as if you are the only patient in the office from the check in to check out...ive been coming here for 5 years...will continue to make the drive from Wapakoneta to Findlay. Thanks for always giving me the best care. This was an old post from probably 2018 it’s now 2023 and I’m 6 weeks post knee replacement surgery I’m so happy I have The JAM squad ! Dr Math and his team are amazing I’m back to work and scheduled the right knee for Sept!rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2023
Dr. McMath, even on a very busy day, takes the time to answer our questions and give advice. He performed my TKR which has been pain free since. My husband will be having a partial knee replacement later this summer. We both feel Dr. McMath is competent and are eager for his surgical expertise.Patient Submitted Review
Mar-2023
Dr McMath is very professional while being very reassuring and kind. Todd, his assistant did a great job explaining things. The entire staff, from the girls at the registration desk, rad tech and discharge staff. So friendly and explaining details very well.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2023
I had the opportunity to go with a friend for their evaluation and to have surgery scheduled. After several visits to follow this entire process I decided if I ever needed any ortho care this is the doctor and facility I want taking care of me. Well that time has arrived and I was not disappointed! Dr. McMath and staff are wonderful and I highly recommend them!!rater8 Verified Patient
Feb-2023
Took the time and looked at all my areas of concern and discussed each one and actually went into the records system to look at older records from a different doctor to help his diagnosis.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2023
Dr McMath’s office has always been fantastic. From the front staff, x-ray tech, the PA, and Libby at the scheduling desk to Tammy in the finance office. They have all taken great care of me. I have had 5 surgeries and scheduled the 6th today. I would not go anywhere else for Orthopedics.rater8 Verified Patient
Jan-2023
Very kind and mild mannered. He talks with you as a person not just another patient. Very pleased with my surgery. He was highly recommended to me from others and I highly recommend him also.rater8 Verified Patient
Dec-2022
Dr. McMath is what every doctor should be. Beside the obviousness of his expertise, he is thorough and informative. However his real strong suit that distinguishes him from other physicians is his interest in what patient has to say.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2022
Dr. McMath asked for details of my problem, how I would rate my pain, and thoroughly examined my knee. He fully explained his diagnoses, plan of action, and if I’m ok with that, or have any questions. I have always found him caring and kind, professional, and highly recommend him.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2022
Dr. McMath is very knowledgeable and helped me understand what was going on with my knees and walked me through the options for treatment in the future as well as providing pain relief today.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2022
Dr McMath performed bilateral full knee replacements about six weeks apart. One year later I could not be any more pleased with his professionalism and his staff. Top notch all the way around.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2022
I love seeing Dr. Mcmath. He is a very friendly person, very knowledgeable, and a very good doctor and surgeon. My knees after my surgery feels great. I haven’t had any problems! So glad he was the one that did my surgery.rater8 Verified Patient
Sep-2022
I’ve been a patient of Dr McMaths for at least 8 years if not longer his staff are truly amazing I ❤️ Every single one of them it is now the time for knee replacement and I honestly feel so good about it . I respected the advice from Dr McMath and PA Dr Todd telling me I’ll know when it’s time. We tried all avenues that worked for many years, but now is time, I HIGHLY recommend Dr McMath and all at Findlay OIOPatient Submitted Review
Sep-2022
This front office reception staff were ok. But Dr McMath staff are outstanding. The nurses were prompt and helpful. Todd Sigler also explained everything and open to questions. Dr McMath is a superior surgeon.Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2022
I always have a good experience when I see Dr McMath. He is very personable and informative during each visit . 14 years after my first hip replacement, & 9 after my second hip, I live a very normal lifestyle. I am very great full for the quality time I have received, from his experience. He is my first choice for any orthopedic issues.Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2022
Office staff well organized. Usually in an exam room by your appointment time. Doctor, Todd, and staff are not rushed. Doctor and Todd explain procedures well and easily answer all questions.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2022
Dr. McMath was great. He answered all my questions, educated me on my issue and presented a solution. All of the employees I dealt were very professional, very friendly and patient. I would highly recommend seeing Dr. McMath.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2022
Dr McMath is very approachable. He explains whatever issue you have in detail so that you have a good understanding of what is going on. He is very thorough in giving the diagnosis and a treatment plan made specifically for you. Most importantly he treats you with kindness, dignity and respect.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2022
Doc is purely professional with a bedside manner to match! He has a natural gentle way about him. He came highly recommended by his piers and for good reason. He is an excellent Surgeon. I am great full his knowledge and skills.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2022
Dr McMath is a caring compassionate doctor who takes time with his patients. Even with his mask on you can tell he is smiling. He has helped me with a number of issues and all have been completely successful. Todd his PA is wonderful too. He assisted with all my surgeries. I wouldn't want to go anywhere else.Patient Submitted Review
May-2022
My daughter had a tire swing incident and injured her wrist, so we decided to have it x-rayed. Todd the PA and Dominic the PA student were wonderful with examining and explaining everything to my daughter as they were doing it. Thank you for your kind care of my daughter!Patient Submitted Review
May-2022
Outstanding!! I had the left done in 2016, the right one 2 weeks ago. Dr. McMath is awesome, Todd, well, he’s amazing. They both make you feel comfortable, safe and explain everything before and after surgery. They answer any and all questions. The rest of the staff is very friendly, except the radiology staff, they are cut and dry. No greeting or anything. They need to work on that. Dr. McMath’s staff, medical assistants and desk are wonderful and knowledgeable. They are very welcoming, I know it’s part of their job, but they go above and beyond. Hopefully, I never need an orthopedic surgery again, but if I do, Dr. McMath is who I am going to.Patient Submitted Review
May-2022
Actually saw Todd Sigler, Dr. McMath's PA. Knowledgeable , answered all questions. The whole office is very efficient...you are in and out at your scheduled time, any wait is shortPatient Submitted Review
Apr-2022
Everyone at Dr. McMath's office, as well as the OIO staff are always so pleasant. I have always been treated with the most respect and have always felt privacy is important to them.rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2022
Dr. McMath is phenominal! He cares so much about his patients care & needs. He's sweet, so nice, & goodlooking! His reputation is why I went to see him & he replaced my hip & knee. He did an outstanding job! I'm so impressed by him that I will help spread the word that he's the doctor people can trust! God Bless him!rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2022
Dr. McMath was very professional. He examined my knee, explained what is going on and shared several options that I can consider. I believe he is in the top 5% of his profession.rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2022
Dr McMath did my total knee replacement a year ago and I have been pain free in that knee since. He will soon be doing surgery on my other knee. I trust him fully, he has a great bedside manner and is an excellent surgeonPatient Submitted Review
Feb-2022
The doctors and overall practice at OIO is outstanding! They were extremely hospitable, extremely professional, and took care of my issue very quickly and efficiently! Dr. McMath is the best ortho doctor/surgeon I have ever had by far! I would rate him well above a 5 out of 5 if I could!Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2022
Excellent care! Very pleased with everyone I came In contact with from the receptionist, nurses, physicians assistant, to Dr. McMath. Would recommend this team of professionals. Carlton FruthPatient Submitted Review
Feb-2022
Dr. McMath did my rotator cuff surgery. Cannot say enough good things about him, his assistant Todd and the staff! They put me at ease, actually listened to me and was so nice! They girls were right on top of my insurance and updates they needed to fax for my time off work, just an amazing experience! I'm choosing them also for my physical therapy. I recommend them without hesitation!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2022
Dr M was so personable and explained what his view was of my injury. I was very comfortable with Dr M. I very happy I switch Drs. I would recommend Dr. M to everyone that has injury and needs good honest treatmentPatient Submitted Review
Jan-2022
Dr. McMath is the kindest, most caring doctor I've seen in a long time...he did my hip replacement, and he explained everything, and seems to honestly care for his patients. Liz and Libby, his nurses, are the greatest also! They make going into his office fun!Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2021
I almost gave 4 stars as they were running an hour late, even with 5 doctors there, but we enjoyed meeting Dr. McMath, and he recommended physical therapy on my knees first. I asked for a cortisone injection for my right knee today. He did not have time to do the left one also, but I was grateful and the procedure has helped me already! No limping, but I still can feel a smaller amount of pain. Big improvement today! I am due back in 6 weeks after therapy.Patient Submitted Review
Dec-2021
Everyone we communicated with were cheerful and helpful. Dr. McMath was very helpful and gave me the feeling he was actually concerned with my case and informed me what he could do for me and how.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2021
Had both my knees replacements checked. Great pictures & great feedback from Dr Mcmath. Love the way he has his office setup with X rays instantly plus rehabilitation all in one place. Great staff is also a plus.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2021
Dr McMath was very professional and attentive to my concern and needs. The staff from the front reception to the attending clinical staff were a pure delight, with smiles on faces and willingness to inform me of each step along the way. I appreciate this office in my care, and would highly recommend them.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2021
Dr. McMath is simply the best! He is professional and personable. He takes time to answer all questions. His demeanor is quiet, yet caring. In addition, his staff is amazing too! Libby always goes above and beyond and is so patient with any questions or concerns. They having been taking care of me for a few years now, for various orthopedic issues. Highly, highly recommend!rater8 Verified Patient
Oct-2021
Dr. McMath is awesome. He has fixed both of my knees and gave me my life back. He has an excellent bed side manor. Very kind and caring man. I would recommend him every time.Patient Submitted Review
Oct-2021
Dr Mcmath is easy to talk to, quick and efficient. I would recommend him for any procedure! This time it was a knee injection, but he also replaced my hip a couple years ago! He is great!Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2021
I have seen Dr McMath several times over the last 5 years. Shoulder injury from a fall. Thumb arthritis, golfers elbow, hip bursitus... he and his Staff have been absolutely outstanding in helping me remain active hunting, swimming and golfing. I am very grateful for their care.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2021
This was my first time seeing Dr. McMath having seen his PA for my hip issue previously. He was very friendly and took the time with me to ask questions and come up with a plan.Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2021
Met with Todd Sigler today. He was caring and listened to what I had to say. He went over the x-rays, examined me and recommended therapy. I was happy at his conservative approach.rater8 Verified Patient
Apr-2021
Dr. McMath really knows his medicine my knees were killing me he was able to pull fluid out of them and replace it with medicine I could feel the difference by the end of the day and by the next day I they felt great! Thank you Dr McMathPatient Submitted Review
Mar-2021
Dr McMath was very patient and detailed at explaining my situation. He also was a pro at giving me a steroid shot in my shoulder. I didn’t feel a thing! Also, his support staff - Libby has been very patient and helpful at every step of the way with scheduling me AND working with my employer for my FMLA leave. Libby has been there every step of the way. Her people skills are second to nonePatient Submitted Review
Feb-2021
Dr. McMath is the real deal. He is very down to earth with you, takes time to listen to your questions and concerns and puts you at great ease. He has helped me out twice in my life and I owe him many pain free days because of his talents. Thank You, Dr. McMathrater8 Verified Patient
Feb-2021
Professional, answers questions and takes time to explain everything. My total knee replacement was absolutely pain free immediately. I would recommend Dr. McMath wholeheartedly.Patient Submitted Review
Feb-2021
Dr. McMath is great, experienced, thorough in his examination, down to earth and widely recognized by his patients as providing consistent positive results. I would highly recommend his services!!Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2021
Visit went very well. I was looking for honest options, not just one, surgery. I was happy with the consult, Dr. Mcmath and staff were very good, answered all of my questions.rater8 Verified Patient
Nov-2020
Dr McMath done my husbands hip surgery a year ago and my husband was able to recover very quickly with the way Dr McMath does it. I visited him with an elbow issue and so far my pain is almost gone with what he did. He is one of the best in his field.Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2020
I think Dr McMath and his team is the best around!!! I have had 2 knees replaced and some hand surgery and I feel like I am serval years younger!!! Thank you for the awesome care and attention your staff gives each patient!!! ❤️❤️Highly recommend them for anyone care and surgery needs!!!Patient Submitted Review
Nov-2020
I Absolutely admire Dr.Mc Math . He is the complete package .... Very professional , kind , caring and I believe the best in our area . He did a knee replacement for me 6 yrars ago . Now my other knee is on the brink of replacement. But I have decided to try Physical thereapy and cortizone first . Trying to delay because of covid . Today a received the shot and he was so kind during the procedure it was over before I Knew it . His staff is just as kind as he . I have referred him to friends and they were so pleases . He is definitely a 10 star in my book !!! Thank u Dr.Mc Math. Well Now it is mid Nov . First response was July 2020 . 15 days post surgery. Again cannot speak more highly of this Awesome Dr. Findlay Hospital took wonderful care of me . Dr. Mc Math again did an amazing job !!! Post op visit went great ! We discussed progress progress ,and therapy ahead . He was patient and kind as always . I can not speak highly enough of Dr.McMath . His staff is kind and friendly. I had health issues which causes me to postpone and reschedule surgery . Libby could not have been more helpful and kind !!! I recommend this Dr. and this surgeon always !!!! Thank you so very much !! And God Bless all of u !rater8 Verified Patient
Aug-2020
Dr. McMath is an outstanding surgeon with an awesome personality and highly skilled and knowledgeable! I will be recommending him to everyone I know that may need an orthopedic doctor!Patient Submitted Review
Aug-2020
Answered all my questions satisfactorily. Helped me to understand my healing process. Also gave me confidence that good progress was being made 6 wks after my knee replacement surgery! Wait was about 25 minutes after being placed in a room.rater8 Verified Patient
Jun-2020
He is very positive and he has a good sense of humor. He makes you feel like you are the only one he has to see. He doesn’t leave the impression that he is in a hurry. He is very confident.Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2020
Dr. McMath and his staff are AWESOME! I recently had a RTKR. He has sincerely understanding to my needs, care and pain management. His staff does a fantastic job with communication, returning calls and showing care for my wellbeing also. I am great full for each of them and highly recommend this team!Patient Submitted Review
Jun-2020
I have been struggling with symptoms for months. Due to visit with McMath, I have answers and a firm path toward healing. Thank heaven I was able to profit by visit there.Patient Submitted Review
May-2020
Dr. McMath is an excellent doctor. He has a very good bedside manner and is always pleasant. He listens to my concerns and I have enjoyed being a patient of his for the last several years. I also think highly of his physician’s assistant, Todd Sigler. He explains things well and is very understanding. I feel I have received excellent care from his team!Patient Submitted Review
May-2020
I would highly recommend Dr. Mcmath. He was a very caring, knowledgeable doctor. Dr Mcmath saw me on my first visit to his office. This gesture definitely has a huge impact on my desire to have Dr. McMath do my total knee replacement. My follow up appointments were always pleasant and Dr Mcmath truly cares about his patients. I would recommend him and his wonderful staff 100%.Patient Submitted Review
May-2020
Top notch, professional, caring, and honest about your condition. I would highly recommend Dr. McMath for any hip or knee surgery. He has done both for me and my results have been amazing.rater8 Verified Patient
May-2020
Top notch doctor and staff. I was totally impressed when Dr Mcmath saw me in my very first appointment at his office. My knee surgery went beautifully. The post visit was also very pleasant.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2020
Dr. McMath is professional and has a great bedside manner! He knew exactly how to relieve my pain from a medical standpoint. He has a lot of experience in his field. Without reservation, I highly recommend him.Patient Submitted Review
Apr-2020
Dr. McMath is very thorough, explains what he is doing and what to expect. Absolutely, I recommend Dr. McMath. He did surgery on my wrist, major bone broke, he inserted a rod and screws several years ago. It has never ached or given me any issues. Whatever needs to be done with my knees, I have complete confidence in his judgement and skill.rater8 Verified Patient
Mar-2020
We saw Dr. McMath’s PA first. He made sure we had all the appropriate X-rays taken. He had Dr. McMath look at them and he came in and gave us the diagnosis. Dr. McMath came in to see us before we left. Very through. Very thankful Libby was able to get us in the day I needed.rater8 Verified Patient
Feb-2020
Dr. McMath's professionalism and expertise are top notch. His staff is the same. I just had a partial knee replacement and have full confidence that my recovery will go smoothly.rater8 Verified Patient
Feb-2020
My knee replacement was a success beyond my best expectations. All that is due to Dr. McMath’s treatment. But especially, he always took the time to explain the procedure, the recovery, and to address my questions and concerns.rater8 Verified Patient
Dec-2019
Dr. McMath provided excellent care. He puts you at ease and because of his skills and expertise my knee replacement went better than I could have anticipated. I would absolutely recommend him to family and friends.rater8 Verified Patient
Nov-2019
I have seen Dr. Mcmath for both a surgery and non surgical management of a number of injuries. He is thorough, pays attention, and explains all of the relevant factors completely.Patient Submitted Review
Jan-2019
My son has been a patient for three years of Dr. Layne's. He's a talented surgeon with impeccable bedside manner. The team is polite and efficient, and the physician assistant, Jordan, is a perfect match.Patient Submitted Review
May-2017
So very happy to have been referred to Dr. McMath. He did total replacement of both of my knees and I am now pain free. My mobility has returned and I could not be more pleased. 62 years old and I am looking for my first Century Ride on my bicycle this August!Patient Submitted Review
Sep-2011
Dr. McMath has now treated and performed surgery on both my daughter and on me, and I would highly recommend him to everyone I know. His bedside manner, professionalism, warmth, and expertise are second to none.Read more
Patient Submitted Review
Jul-2025
Dr. McMath is great. He great bedside manner, understands your condition completely and won’t put his patient thru procedures that aren’t necessary. Just an all around great doctor and I’ve highly recommended him to friends. Their feelings are the same. I drive from Maumee to see him when there are other orthopedic doctors much closer and I have absolutely no regrets.