Dr. Timothy Petsche is a board-certified physician who specializes in orthopedic surgery and sports medicine. He treats people of all ages who are in pain from a sports, work comp, accident, or over-use injury using an evidence-based, data-driven scientific method to maximize healing. Dr. Petsche completed his Residency in Orthopedic Surgery with the University of Illinois at Chicago.
Dr. Timothy Petsche is a board-certified physician who specializes in orthopedic surgery and sports medicine. He treats people of all ages who are in pain from a sports, work comp, accident, or over-use injury using an evidence-based, data-driven scientific method to maximize healing. Dr. Petsche completed his Residency in Orthopedic Surgery with the University of Illinois at Chicago.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Fox Valley Orthopedics through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
Dr. Petsche is probably one of the best surgeons you can get he's very straightforward, but takes his time explaining every little detail so you feel comfortable with the procedure! 10/10 recommend
(4 days ago)
May-2026
Fantastic! Excellent job in preparation for our daughter’s ACL surgery. We appreciate his directness and explanation on every step. Highly recommend!
(1 week ago)
May-2026
Intelligent, friendly and compassionate.
(2 weeks ago)
May-2026
Amazing surgeon who takes the time to thoughtfully answer your questions and ensure that you’re choosing the best treatment options. His entire team has been amazing to work with throughout my surgery and recovery!
(2 weeks ago)
May-2026
Simply the best!! I can’t believe how well that scope went. I actually haven’t even needed to take any pain medication. Thanks Doc!!!
(2 weeks ago)
May-2026
All good and no pain! 😍
(1 month ago)
Apr-2026
He is an amazing doctor and his bedside manner is second to none. I’d recommend him to everyone I know.
(1 month ago)
Apr-2026
Very informative and very professional. So far so good.
(1 month ago)
Apr-2026
Dr. Petsche is clearly knowledgeable, and he referenced statistics and studies with ease. However, my low rating reflects the way that knowledge was delivered. At times, it felt less like he was trying to support the patient and more like he was showcasing what he knew, rather than offering empathy or understanding. He also made assumptions and stereotypical comments that were unnecessary and, incorrect. His delivery lacked warmth, especially when telling a patient that their season was over.
Additionally, the front desk staff were chatting among themselves, which didn’t create a welcoming environment for a new patient.
(1 month ago)
Mar-2026
Explain all my options and told me one couldn't be selected because of diabetes, exam was through and showed me what is causing the pain and why it affects me more in the morning
Dr. Timothy Petsche is a board-certified physician who specializes in orthopedic surgery and sports medicine. He treats people of all ages who are in pain from a sports, work comp, accident, or over-use injury using an evidence-based, data-driven scientific method to maximize healing. Dr. Petsche completed his Residency in Orthopedic Surgery with the University of Illinois at Chicago.
With extensive experience in the field of sports medicine, Dr. Petsche offers the latest advancements in orthopedic treatments. Patients receive comprehensive diagnosis and treatment options, with risks and benefits discussed. Patients also receive extensive education so they can make informed decisions based on their own health and expectations.
Dr. Petsche works with a team that includes medical assistants, nurses, physician assistants, and others to provide the best comprehensive care. Each team member works closely with physical and occupational therapists to help patients regain pain-free range of motion, strength, and function after injury or surgery.
An athlete himself, Dr. Petsche prides himself as someone who athletes and sports enthusiasts can relate to. From participation in such youth sports as baseball, football, basketball, soccer, gymnastics and golf, Dr. Petsche went on to compete in All-State and All-American springboard diving in high school. At the University of Michigan, Dr. Petsche was an accomplished Division 1 athlete, and member of the swim and diving team that went on to win four consecutive Big Ten championships during his tenure. Today, Dr. Petsche enjoys golf, mountain bike riding, disc golf, swimming, lifting weights, water and snow skiing, wake surfing, badminton, pickleball, and hiking.
Dr. Petsche is probably one of the best surgeons you can get he's very straightforward, but takes his time explaining every little detail so you feel comfortable with the procedure! 10/10 recommend
Fantastic! Excellent job in preparation for our daughter’s ACL surgery. We appreciate his directness and explanation on every step. Highly recommend!
Intelligent, friendly and compassionate.
Amazing surgeon who takes the time to thoughtfully answer your questions and ensure that you’re choosing the best treatment options. His entire team has been amazing to work with throughout my surgery and recovery!
Simply the best!! I can’t believe how well that scope went. I actually haven’t even needed to take any pain medication. Thanks Doc!!!
All good and no pain! 😍
He is an amazing doctor and his bedside manner is second to none. I’d recommend him to everyone I know.
Very informative and very professional. So far so good.
Dr. Petsche is clearly knowledgeable, and he referenced statistics and studies with ease. However, my low rating reflects the way that knowledge was delivered. At times, it felt less like he was trying to support the patient and more like he was showcasing what he knew, rather than offering empathy or understanding. He also made assumptions and stereotypical comments that were unnecessary and, incorrect. His delivery lacked warmth, especially when telling a patient that their season was over. Additionally, the front desk staff were chatting among themselves, which didn’t create a welcoming environment for a new patient.
Explain all my options and told me one couldn't be selected because of diabetes, exam was through and showed me what is causing the pain and why it affects me more in the morning