Dr. Matthew Gotlin is a fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon who specializes in sports medicine. His clinical focus is the operative and non-operative treatment of athletes of all ages and skill levels, including pediatric, adolescent, and adult athletes. He is trained in advanced arthroscopy, complex reconstruction, and cartilage restoration procedures of the hip, knee, ankle, shoulder, and elbow. He also performs joint replacements for arthritis of the hip, knee, and shoulder.
Dr. Matthew Gotlin is a fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon who specializes in sports medicine. His clinical focus is the operative and non-operative treatment of athletes of all ages and skill levels, including pediatric, adolescent, and adult athletes. He is trained in advanced arthroscopy, complex reconstruction, and cartilage restoration procedures of the hip, knee, ankle, shoulder, and elbow. He also performs joint replacements for arthritis of the hip, knee, and shoulder.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of NY Orthopedics through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
Excellent
(3 days ago)
Jan-2026
Never got to see him
(1 week ago)
Jan-2026
Clean office - friendly staff - short wait
knowledgeable Doctor
(1 week ago)
Dec-2025
The office was well run and Dr Gotlin was informative and spent unrushed time with me. Everything was explained well.
(2 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
Great Doctor so compassionate and truly cares about his patients I would highly recommend him.
(3 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
Take the time to listen and share with me the best treatment for my injuries
(3 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
I recently underwent ACL reconstruction with Dr. Gotlin, and I can confidently say I could not have chosen a better surgeon. From the very first consultation, he took the time to explain every detail of my injury, my options, and what to expect before and after surgery. He never rushed a single question and made sure I felt fully prepared going into the procedure.
On surgery day, Dr. Gotlin and his entire team were incredible. They made me feel calm, informed, and genuinely cared for. The professionalism, attention to detail, and bedside manner were top-tier. After waking up from surgery, everything he said would happen matched exactly—no surprises, just clarity and confidence.
(1 month ago)
Dec-2025
I am very happy with my decision to visit Dr Matthew Gotlin office
(1 month ago)
Dec-2025
Dr. Gotlin cares deeply about his patients, gives them room and comfortably to ask as many questions as they need, and is an incredibly talented surgeon
(1 month ago)
Dec-2025
All my visits were very well done - received all the info I needed
(1 month ago)
Dec-2025
Read More
Scarsdale
2 Overhill Rd Suite 310 Scarsdale, NY 10583
Manhattan - 74th St
159 East 74th Street Mezzanine & 2nd Floor New York, NY 10021
Dr. Matthew Gotlin is a fellowship-trained orthopedic surgeon who specializes in sports medicine. His clinical focus is the operative and non-operative treatment of athletes of all ages and skill levels, including pediatric, adolescent, and adult athletes. He is trained in advanced arthroscopy, complex reconstruction, and cartilage restoration procedures of the hip, knee, ankle, shoulder, and elbow. He also performs joint replacements for arthritis of the hip, knee, and shoulder.
Dr. Gotlin is a Magna Cum Laude graduate from Penn State University’s Eberly College of Science. He completed medical school at the Stony Brook School of Medicine in New York. At Stony Brook he was inducted into the Alpha Omega Alpha Honors Society, recipient of the Stony Brook School of Medicine Academic Merit Award, and recipient of the overall Clinical Excellence award. He then completed his orthopedic surgery residency training at the prestigious NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital in New York City. He was the recipient of the 2019 Herodicus Award for Best Resident Paper at the AOSSM annual meeting. During his final year of residency he was selected and served as Executive Chief Resident. After residency, Dr. Gotlin completed a fellowship in Orthopedic Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City .
Dr. Gotlin is currently the team physician for the Harlem Wizards men’s professional basketball team. He has served as an assistant team physician for the NFL’s New York Jets, the NFL scouting combine, and the National Women’s Hockey League’s Metropolitan Riveters. He also has experience at the collegiate level where he served as an assistant team physician for the NYU and LIU athletic programs, as well as assistant team physician for the Manhattanville men’s hockey team. Dr. Gotlin has extensive experience caring for high school and adolescent athlete’s and has also provided medical care for the NYC Marathon as well as to the dancers of Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater.
Dr. Gotlin has published numerous book chapters and scientific papers in peer-reviewed journals. He is a member of the American Orthopedic Society for Sports Medicine, Arthroscopy Association of North America, and the American Association of Orthopaedic Medicine.
Excellent
Never got to see him
Clean office - friendly staff - short wait knowledgeable Doctor
The office was well run and Dr Gotlin was informative and spent unrushed time with me. Everything was explained well.
Great Doctor so compassionate and truly cares about his patients I would highly recommend him.
Take the time to listen and share with me the best treatment for my injuries
I recently underwent ACL reconstruction with Dr. Gotlin, and I can confidently say I could not have chosen a better surgeon. From the very first consultation, he took the time to explain every detail of my injury, my options, and what to expect before and after surgery. He never rushed a single question and made sure I felt fully prepared going into the procedure. On surgery day, Dr. Gotlin and his entire team were incredible. They made me feel calm, informed, and genuinely cared for. The professionalism, attention to detail, and bedside manner were top-tier. After waking up from surgery, everything he said would happen matched exactly—no surprises, just clarity and confidence.
I am very happy with my decision to visit Dr Matthew Gotlin office
Dr. Gotlin cares deeply about his patients, gives them room and comfortably to ask as many questions as they need, and is an incredibly talented surgeon
All my visits were very well done - received all the info I needed