Dr. Katie O'Grady, M.D., is board-certified in Family Medicine. She attended Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School and trained at Mount Sinai Downtown Residency in Urban Family Medicine. She was voted Chief Resident by her peers in her last year of training. After residency, Dr. O’Grady worked at The Floating Hospital in Long Island City, NY, providing full-scope family medicine for families living in temporary housing in NYC.
Dr. Katie O'Grady, M.D., is board-certified in Family Medicine. She attended Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School and trained at Mount Sinai Downtown Residency in Urban Family Medicine. She was voted Chief Resident by her peers in her last year of training. After residency, Dr. O’Grady worked at The Floating Hospital in Long Island City, NY, providing full-scope family medicine for families living in temporary housing in NYC.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Consensus Health Primary Care Med-Care through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
Dr. New my issue right away.
And issued a prescription at my pharmacy
(1 week ago)
Feb-2026
Great doctor ! Very thorough! Pleasant personality .. just love her !
(1 week ago)
Feb-2026
What a great doctor and staff
(1 week ago)
Feb-2026
Personable, friendly, professional and thorough! She took a lot of time to ask questions, explain and listen which is all a patient can ask for. Greatly miss the doctors Scolamiero but so happy to go forward with Dr. O'Grady!
(2 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
Very nice, easy to talk to.
(2 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
Knowledgeable, professional,
Prepared, and considerate. A very worthy office visit.
(2 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
Very thorough and personable.
(3 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
Dr O’Grady is terrific!
(1 month ago)
Feb-2026
Veey "Professional. Takes time to listen and answer my questions.
(1 month ago)
Feb-2026
She is professional and covers everything with my health.
(1 month ago)
Jan-2026
Read More
Consensus Health Primary Care Med-Care - East Rutherford
Consensus Health Primary Care Med-Care - Fairfield
Dr. Katie O'Grady, M.D., is board-certified in Family Medicine. She attended Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School and trained at Mount Sinai Downtown Residency in Urban Family Medicine. She was voted Chief Resident by her peers in her last year of training. After residency, Dr. O’Grady worked at The Floating Hospital in Long Island City, NY, providing full-scope family medicine for families living in temporary housing in NYC. She then worked at Everside Health (now Marathon Health) for 3 years before joining the Consensus Health team. She loves primary care and also supports women’s health, obesity medicine, pediatrics, and mental health.
Outside of work, Dr. O’Grady loves dancing, writing, and running. She has self-published 2 children’s books for fun and has run 3 marathons. She loves spending time with her 2 young daughters.
See other doctors in Consensus Health Primary Care Med-Care
Dr. New my issue right away. And issued a prescription at my pharmacy
Great doctor ! Very thorough! Pleasant personality .. just love her !
What a great doctor and staff
Personable, friendly, professional and thorough! She took a lot of time to ask questions, explain and listen which is all a patient can ask for. Greatly miss the doctors Scolamiero but so happy to go forward with Dr. O'Grady!
Very nice, easy to talk to.
Knowledgeable, professional, Prepared, and considerate. A very worthy office visit.
Very thorough and personable.
Dr O’Grady is terrific!
Veey "Professional. Takes time to listen and answer my questions.
She is professional and covers everything with my health.