J. Thompson McMurtrie, MD

Very competent and eager to help. Explained my options and made suggestions for future treatment. Made appointment with a back/spine specialist to follow up as my biggest problem or additional problem could be emanating from my low back. Very professional.

Dr. Murrieta is a great doctor. He is kind and honest He does a great job explaining the current situation and all possible outcomes. And willing to answer any questions and concerns. A+!

Dr, McMurtrie, is an awesome Orthopedic doctor who treated me with respect, dignity and care when I visited him for my left shoulder rotator cuff tear at TOC, Madison location. I was under his care for almost two years. His feedback always provided me with self-assurance of what to expect for recovery after surgery. More importantly, Dr. McMurtrie cares a lot about the patient and provided me with excellent care to include recommendations in the best interest of surgery or helping with pain management. I had to put off surgery due to relocating to Williamsburg, Virginia. I was looking forward to having Dr. McMurtrie do a reverse shoulder rotator replacement surgery this fall. He was more than willing to recommend an Orthopaedic surgeon located in the area. I will be remised if I didn’t provide a positive review for his thorough findings and unwavering care.

Helped me fully understand my condition and options. Patients. Showed concern for my other developing medical issues and directed me to see my primary doctor right away. I did not feel like he wanted to hurry me out.

Dr . McMurtrie was very knowledgeable and addressed my issue with leaving me feeling valued and listened to. I would definitely recommend him.

Great Doctor

No Words! He was excellent and was able to give a solid path forward.

He is awesome!

Extremely prompt, courteous and professional.

Thanks to all!!!

He really helped my right knee pain with a steroid shot. It is already helping! Thank you so much I can walk much better.

He is very nice

God truly Blessed our family when he allowed Dr McMurtrie and his staff come into our lives!! We appreciate and love them dearly!!

Genuinely concerned from day one..

Listened to my concerns and explained everything to me in detail.

Listened well and his demeanor was kind.

AWSOME doctor! Explained everything in detail and what I could expect in the future.

Timely and great service

Very happy with the care I receive

He listens and discusses things and options. Great communicator.

Dr McMurtrie was very Pleasant. Immediately he tried to figure out my problem and recommended different options to help me out with my knee

Very good service

Great Ortho Dr. He is very knowable, caring, an takes time to understand the problem and find the solution!!

Dr. McMurtrie is very thorough and takes the time needed to diagnose problems. His bedside manner is the best of any doctor I see. He’s the go-to for me and my husband.

Great doctor who cares for his patients

A straightforward with you he checked me over real good and give me some good advice on my shoulder see I have a small tear in my rotary cup area already on top but it's not bad enough to cut on so we're going to use physical therapy to try to straighten it out where most doctors would have wanted to just cut on me I like the cutting the last thing he'll do all round great guy

Another great visit. Great dialogue and excellent medical advice received!

Terrific!

Great doctor

Excellent

Professional and listen to me. Amen

I love Dr McMurtrie!!! I highly recommend him. My rotator cuff/bicep surgery is healing nicely.

Not only the best Dr. Ever had he's the only one that is concerned about your overall health and shares some of his personal life so 🤷 know a little about him

Great Doctor !

Dr. McMurtrie explained every aspect of my upcoming surgery in terms anyone could understand. If I had any questions, he answered them to the fullest!

Explains everything well. And answers all my questions.

Love my doctor! Very attentive and considerate, cares about your pain and suffering.

Excellent care !!!

Nice to meet a surgeon who isn't set on surgery being the only option.

I was surprised at the excellent care that I received from Dr. McMurrtrie. I'm just used to the standard Orthopedic Doctors, but Dr. McMurtrie went beyond to excellent.

I love that he really listens to me and helps me to understand all my options.

The staff was very friendly, nice and helpful.

Very informative and nice.

So sweet and understandkng! I appreciate very muvh!

Great! Totally took time with me and I appreciate it!

Dr. McMurtie is very friendly and takes the time to really listen to your concerns and answer questions.

Very nice and was detailed about explaining my MRI. Really seemed like he cared. Great DR.

Listened to my concern. Fully explained treatment options. Answered all my questions.

Listened to my concerns and gave me the advice and exercises to improve my health. Was very patient and

Terrific service..professional, knowledgeable.

Always a great experience! Dr. McMurtrie is honest and willing to have a discussion about treatments and ways ahead.

I really like Dr. McMurtrie, however this is the 2nd time I've had an appointment and had to wait over an hour to be seen.

Listens and has a lot of knowledge.

DrMcMurttie is an excellent physician and is very patient and caring and takes time to explain what ever the patient needs.

Informative & friendly…

Explained everything in a way that was easy to understand

Fast, efficient and knowledgeable

He has a great bedside manner. At my age i appreciate that alot.

I would recommend , very good doctor.

Took time to explain my injury as well as options Should I choose surgery I will definitely choose this Dr

Confident, knowledgeable, friendly, listens well

He offered me options for my treatment and discussed and answered my question in laymen terms.

Polite and efficient, great personality!

Dr McMurtrie is kind and listens, he's very personable snd knowledgeable and answered all of my questions!

Personable!

Great communicator. Excellent bedside manor. Easy to talk to about any health related concerns.

Dr. McMurtrie was excellent at asking the right questions and listening. He prescribed a reasonable approach to solving the condition. He had a great bed side manner

On Time--Listened to me--Provided me with options to consider--

I think my issue was far too advanced for him to provide advice for, so all he did was refer me to one of his associates that might be more credible or helpful. I expected treatment or advice when I made the effort to come for the visit. Nice guy though.

Good visit.

Very nice and courteous. Listen to your concerns.

Mr. McMurtrie is very professional and very knowledgeable in his expertise. He prayed for me before surgery which tells me that he's very understanding and caring. I love his team as well who were very nice and friendly.

Very understanding and patient

It wouldn’t let me give him 5 stars

Absolutely awesome!

Excellent. Very caring

Excellent professional diagnosis and treatment. Great personality. Easy to talk to and put me at ease

I’m two weeks post-op from hip arthroscopic surgery and feel great so far. I’m not sure if it’s me or Dr. McMurtrie but I have a feeling he had something to do with it ;). Thanks to you and the team for the care and expertise Doc!

Shoulders feel great good job James is

Friendly and thoroughly explained all treatment options available to me.

Dr McMurtrie is always smiling and attentive to my issues and gets right to the point of problem and my choices. Thank you once again.

First time see him and I was pleased !

Dr. M has been very caring and helpful in my ongoing hip pain.

Highly recommended. Dr McMurtrie is the best!!

Cares about me wellbeing

Definitely a star doc! Totally exceeded my expectations.

Dr McMurtrie was very professional while taking the time to completely check and explain my knee problem. He gave me a shot and list of exercises. Already experiencing less pain. Thank uou

Very nice good humor

excellent bedside manner. explains things very well for the patient to understand.

This was my first time seeing him and he is wonderful. Explained my options and answered my questions.

All went well and he explained my situation clearly. I am happy! 😇😇😇

Thank you for your clarity, honesty, and accountability. Your accumen and diagnostic skills , knows no bounds. It has been the highlight of my pedestrian existence to drive 120 miles round trip to experience this phenomenon called TOC. O thank you for allowing me to spend thousands of dollars to be your patient. Although I still hurt like before, thank you for confirming what web md told back last January. I have a

Great appointment with Dr, McMurtie! Very thorough with a great bedside manner!

Great visit. Good attitude! Straight forward on assessment. Clear communication. Definitely will recommend to others!

very pleased with the services

Good followup appt.

dool dude

although busy, Dr McMurtie was genuinely concerned about my condition and addressed it immediately answering questions i had

Understanding and easy to discuss issues with.

Kind quick and patient!

Great bedside manner, very compassionate

Excellent bedside manner and overall experience!

Awesome Dr. as well as an awesome person. Listens and responds to concerns to make sure you understand every step in the process. Works definitely recommend to anyone on the fence about their choice or surgeon.

Dr. McMurtrie is always so kind. He listens to my concerns and addresses them.

excellent bedside manner

Easy to talk to. Did a thorough examination of my knee. Was concerned that I might have a blood clot. Will go to him again if the need arises.

Kind, compassionate.

Fantastic

Very knowledgeable and professional and caring doctor. Gives you all your options about your care while giving his honest opinion. Will use him for all my orthopaedic needs. Highly recommend.

Very glad he is my sugeon

When I first went to Dr. McMurtrie, he suggested giving a shot in my knee for my pain. My first response was “NO”. I finally let him and it made my knee so much better! Dr. McMurtrie listens and cares about his patient.

Thorough and professional

Thank you so much!

Very professional and courteous.

Always making sure he answers our questions and making sure he does what’s best for her. Thank you

Dr. McMurtrie was very thorough in explaining options and possible negative outcomes to treatment. He did not rush and took the time to make sure I understood all of my options.

Kind, knowledgeable, professional, helpful!!

Good care provider that listens to what you have to say and what your needs are to best correlate a course of care.

Great consult and precise successful treatment.

Apparently a nice piece of work done on my shoulder. Was well informed through the whole process.

He was comprehensive, friendly, and through. I recommend him.

GOOD BEDSIDE MANOR

Really like him! Friendly and kind. Ask questions and listens.

Dr. McMurtrie is prompt, efficient and kind. So grateful he did my surgery.

He was friendly but professional. He explained everything clearly, answered my questions, etc. I'd certainly see him again if needed and recommend him to thers.

Good doctor, answered all my questions and listened to my complaints.

Friendly, personable, and thorough in explanation.

Great bedside manner. Listens to your complaints and willing to try to help.

Dr McMurtrie is emphatic and listens to his patients' needs. Recommend .

Very nice.

This doctor is wonderful. His bedside manner is caring and respectful. His surgical skills have helped me so much!

Dr. McMurtrie is knowledgeable, thorough, and quite personable. He considered my case with great care, and was mindful of all aspects as he presented me with choices while navigating a treatment plan.

He looks out for your best medical interests.

He didn’t have any interest in listening to what I was saying.

Excellent

Dr. McMurtrie did an excellent job repairing my shoulder. Would definitely recommend him for any orthopedic problem.

Took time to listen and answer questions.

He took time with me and listened to what I was saying. He was knowledgeable about my health history and administrated treatment that was best for my health issue.

I was happy he could see me on a short notice. I thought he would be the surgeon.

Dr. McMurtrie listened to me and understand what I needed.

Very personal and informative. Gave me several options for my issues

Knowledgeable, practical,

Very professional yet also very personable glad he is my surgeon

Dr McMurtrie has a very good bedside manner. He listens and cares about the patient and their needs.

Very caring and professional.

Wonderful doc takes all the time you need, answers all question

I am so happy to have Dr McMurtrie as my doctor. I appreciate his expertise. His approach to conservative measures first makes sense to me. He went above expectations today as he asked if he could pray for my mom and my family.

Dr. McMurtrie is all about patient well being. After my surgery, I had some complications (DVT which led to an embolism and infarction) and he called and stopped by to check on me multiple times to make sure I was doing well. He is truly a one of a kind physician.

Dr. McMurtrie took time to diagnose my ankle problem. He was very patient when I described my issue. He paid attention to every detail I had said. I would definitely recommend him to my friend.

He listens and care.

Very informative and professional.

Great doctor. Caring and interested.

Easily explained in terms I understood. Came up with a fairly non-evasive plan.

Very personable and thorough in exam and treatment … I like Drs who explain in laymen’s terms

Attentive, willing to work with my budget constraints, informative.

Explains and discusses problem and offers possible solutions.

Always as usual top-notch patient care Dr McMurtrie’s attentiveness to detail gives a whole new meaning to satisfied clients, his staff all working proficiently to ensure your comfortability is always 100%, if more doctors had his mannerism it would elevate many peoples fear of visiting any health facility.

Works with you to help achieve a full recovery.

Dr. McMurtrie made this stressful and painful experience EASY! He gave full attention as if I was the only patient!

Dr. McMurtrie was very attentive, a great listener. He seemed to want to initiate the healing process, not another 'customer'.

Dr McMurtrie is sympathetic and reassuring.

Dr. McMurtrie was really great! He Listened to my problems and payed a lot of attention to detail. He tried hard to diagnose the issue. I would definitely recommend him!

Dr. McMurtrie is an excellent physician. He takes the time to listen and address concerns and offers his best medical advice. 100% comfortable and confident in his abilities.

Very professional, knowledgeable and friendly. He was accommodating and explained options very well.

Very friendly, cordial, helpful, very knowlegable of the condition of my knee. I like him a lot.

He was really good. He introduced himself self and went straight to work. He told us what the problem was and what to do to fix it, and I really like the fact that he didn’t try to push any extra as far as anything we didn’t need on us.

Very friendly, personable and compassionate. He spent plenty of time with me explaining the diagnosis and treatment options.

Loved the time he took, he was kind and asked good questions, I felt he understood my pain!

My experience with TOC and Dr McMurtrie were great. Patricia Shamlin

Excellent doctor, answered my questions and recommended conservative approach to my problems. Very knowledgeable as well

I left my first meeting with Dr. McMurtrie feeling like I would be in great hands! Dr. Davis had referred me to him for knee replacement surgery and I am happy he accepted me as his patient.

Very experienced new doctor

Dr McMurtrie has been a pleasure to work with through my diagnosis and treatment. He listens and is very thorough in his treatment plans.

Doctor was a nice enough guy but like most doctors I've seen at TOC they spend about a minute to a minute and a half in the room with you before they run off to their next patient. It would be nice if doctors would spend a little bit of time to at least make me feel like they looked at the issue before running away

He was extremely caring and provided good advice

Friendly, listens, thorough, to the point and gives clear and straight forward feed back.

My husband and I had an appointment this morning, but I fell and hurt my elbow and he was more concerned about my elbow. He was on top of getting my elbow totaling Carr of. And then he called me when I left the er. He his an awesome doctor.

Good doctor and good human.

Thoroughly good examination

Excellent dr

Great interpersonal and communication skills.

Very tentative to my concerns. Listened to everything I said.

Dr. McMurtrie is excellent. He is very thorough and listens to your concerns. I felt very comfortable talking to him. He gives you the best options to fix your problems.

Spends the time to listen, to really understand and provide the best solution. Double-checks important details.

This was my first appointment with Dr. McMurtrie and found him to be very thorough. A total knee replacement is a quite involved surgery and he explained it in quite detail.

Dr. McMurtrie and the TOC staff have been both professional and personable. Dr. McMurtrie has provided exceptional health care and testing - his expertise has resulted in a successful outcome for my issues with hip. Very happy with my experience with the TOC!

Very attentive with a proactive approach to managing and minimizing right knee pain.

Really appreciate the time he took and working to get a better xray.

A great visit!

Ever friendly and very thoughtful.

Very caring and concern for his patients

Very personable and thorough.

Knowledgeable but not gentle. Apologetic when he hurts you. I will go back because his treatment worked.

Personal, wait was good, and I think he knows his stuff.

Excellent surgeon!

Dr McMurtrie is awesome! I'm seeing him for my knees and I really like that he gives me all options, it's not a 1 size fits all. He's very kind and patient.

So far so good.

He took at the time to answer all off our questions and we left feeling very comfortable with his recommendations.

Very knowledgeable, pleasant, and caring

Very personable and excellent at explaining treatments and procedures.

First visit went good. Thanks

smart, kind, understanding and really compassionate. helped with sm PT exercises to start and came to check on me Saturday!!!!

He’s great at Getting you in and getting you out without anyone feeling like you’re just another patient . Which is great for me because I work nights

Love Doc McMurtrie!

Excellent physician.

X ray tech not very friendly? Everyone else was wonderful.

He took the time to explain my pain and and the road best taken.

Very pleasant and helpful!

Very pleasant and patient with this old lady. I was a nervous reck but he soothed me down. He was through informative.

Great doctor. Straight to the point.

Very professional. Diagnosed me within mins from only a X-ray.

He is very caring and takes the time to listen to your concerns.

Excellent service! My experience with Dr. McMurtrie was great. He quickly assessed my condition and provided the best treatment care for my relief. Grateful not to be in pain!

First time to see orthopedic doc. Very pleased. Good personality.

Very nice and good at his job. Awesome Doctor.

Great experience. Very knowledgeable and listened to all my concerns. He was a great help.

Straight Up , A Straight Forward, I like his Professionalism.

Patiently talks me through possibilities and options, doesn’t push for unnecessary tests.

Professional, comprehensive, very comfortable manner. On time!

Very nice and listens well

Dr. McMurtrie is a very good doctor. He is very professional and explains the procedures really well. I appreciated him praying with me before my surgery. God bless him!

Took time to listen to me and examine me.

I appreciate that he discussed my options with me and didn't pressure me to pick a specific one.

Listened, answered my questions, was kind and professional, and gave me effective treatment. Pretty much everything I want from a healthcare provider.

Very friendly and knowledgeable.

Dr. McMurtrie is very personable. He took his time to actually listen to me. He was very thorough and answered all of my questions. I highly recommend him.

He was very thorough in investigating what could be causing my pain. Very much appreciate the care and concern.

Excellent very thorough explains everything, not rushed

Excellent bedside manner- excellent explanation of my situation and clearly laid out the options going forward.

Great doc and good fella

Even though he was running behind schedule, he came in an immediately apologize for that. I felt very valued by him and he gave me his full attention, along with options instead of surgery being my only option.

Took the time to talk. Very personable.

Extremely caring and personable. Did a great job on my shoulder.

So caring!

Did a great job of explaining what was going on with my tennis elbow.

Dr. McMurtrie, is awesome, he's kind, caring, and he listens. It's so hard to find anyone that truly listens to people anymore. My heart was so heavy at our last visit, I was struggling with personal issues, he noticed that I wasn't myself and asked is everything okay. It wasn't and I broke down. He took the time to pray for me and allowed me to release. I will never forget that, or him.

Great interaction and upfront with options and was receptive to how I wanted to proceed.

Dr. McMurtrie is wonderful. He is very personable, His explanations are thorough and understandable. He spends time to listen to your concerns and answer questions. I feel as though he truly cares.

1st time visit, seemed like a very nice gentleman. Easy to talk to a listened to everything I had to say before offering any treatment.

excellent

Best doctor!!! Dr. McMurtrie performed a knee surgery for my mom and he was thorough, answered every question and just cared. I have been to many different doctors but by far, Dr. McMurtrie and his team are really the best!

Super kind and informative! Apologized for being late!

Very willing to listen and discuss options in order to come to consensus on a clear path forward.

Very caring and knowledgeable physician. Highly recommend.

Dr. McMurtrie is very thorough & detailed when examining his patients. He shows that he cares and wants what is best. I would highly recommend him

Very kind and knowledgeable.

Would give a 5 but I am still broken…..will update when fixed.

DR. McMurtrie was very nice and appeared interested in my condition and symptoms. He offered several available options to address my condition and didn't push any specific one. I hope I don't have anthor injury, but if I do I'll see Dr. McMurtrie.

Dr McMurtrie very kind and did great with my sons boxer fracture.

Excellent doctor. He takes time to answer questions and explain procedures. It meant a lot when he prayed with me before my surgery. I am also a Christian. Excellent nurse,

So thorough with his explanations, I could tell he truly cared about helping me get back to 100%. Trust this man with your knee.