Dr. James J. Creighton, III is board certified by the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery. After his freshman year at Indiana University, Dr. Creighton transferred to the University of Notre Dame, receiving his Bachelor of Science. He then attended Indiana University School of Medicine, and after graduating, he stayed there for his orthopedic surgery residency. Dr. Creighton then did two fellowships to specialize in upper extremity surgery.
Dr. James J. Creighton, III is board certified by the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery. After his freshman year at Indiana University, Dr. Creighton transferred to the University of Notre Dame, receiving his Bachelor of Science. He then attended Indiana University School of Medicine, and after graduating, he stayed there for his orthopedic surgery residency. Dr. Creighton then did two fellowships to specialize in upper extremity surgery.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Florida Orthopaedic Institute through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
Dr. Creighton is as good as it gets. He explained all my issues very clearly, the causes, and gave me options for treatment. I left with a great understanding of my problems and that gave me confidence in moving ahead. Highly recommend Dr. Creighton.
(1 week ago)
Apr-2026
He made me feel very comfortable. Explained to me so I could understand what he was saying about the injury. He gave me his recommendation and I agree.
(1 week ago)
Apr-2026
Great
(2 weeks ago)
Apr-2026
Great staff!
(2 weeks ago)
Apr-2026
Dr Creighton and his colleague explained everything I needed to know in friendly and in clear manner, including addressing my concerns about my injury to extent where I was thoroughly satisfied,
(2 weeks ago)
Apr-2026
Excellent surgeon and very nice man!
(3 weeks ago)
Mar-2026
Had the initial meeting with Dr. Creighton for a rotator cuff tear. He was nice and answered all my questions. He gave me the option of watching and waiting vs surgery and told me about the side effects and recovery period. He also showed me a picture online of what the repair will look like. So far, everything went smooth and I am not stressed about the surgery anymore. I feel like I am in good hands and just want to get it done with.
(3 weeks ago)
Mar-2026
Expeditious, informative, and caring attention
(3 weeks ago)
Mar-2026
Cariing, effective and proactive. He's helllped me numerous times with my hands, wrists and shoulder. Plus, he's a fellow Hoosier!
The only drawback is wait times often run long. Be prepared.
(3 weeks ago)
Mar-2026
Dr Creighton is easy to talk with and he answer my questions. I would love to have him do my shoulder surgery but I am moving back home and will continue my care there. Thank you for your expertise.
Dr. James J. Creighton, III is board certified by the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery. He grew up in Indianapolis, Indiana, and became a diehard Notre Dame fan at an early age. After his freshman year at Indiana University, Dr. Creighton transferred to the University of Notre Dame, receiving his Bachelor of Science. He then attended Indiana University School of Medicine, and after graduating, he stayed there for his orthopedic surgery residency. Dr. Creighton then did two fellowships to specialize in upper extremity surgery. The first was with the Indiana Hand to Shoulder Center, focusing on hand, upper extremity, and microsurgery. The second was a Shoulder and Elbow fellowship with Florida Orthopaedic Institute.
Dr. Creighton cares for all upper extremity conditions, including fracture care, arthritis, tendon and ligament injuries, nerve decompression and repair, Dupuytren’s disease, arthroplasty, and arthroscopy. He cares for patients of all ages. Dr. Creighton’s goal is to get patients back to their regular activities as soon as possible by working as a team with caregivers, family, and other medical professionals.
He is a member of the American Society for Surgery of the Hand, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons, and the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.
Dr. Creighton spends his spare time with his wife and two sons. Together, they enjoy outdoor activities such as golf, skiing, snowboarding, hiking, and time at the beach and in the water. Dr. Creighton also enjoys traveling, grilling, and watching sporting events.
See other doctors in Florida Orthopaedic Institute
Dr. Creighton is as good as it gets. He explained all my issues very clearly, the causes, and gave me options for treatment. I left with a great understanding of my problems and that gave me confidence in moving ahead. Highly recommend Dr. Creighton.
He made me feel very comfortable. Explained to me so I could understand what he was saying about the injury. He gave me his recommendation and I agree.
Great
Great staff!
Dr Creighton and his colleague explained everything I needed to know in friendly and in clear manner, including addressing my concerns about my injury to extent where I was thoroughly satisfied,
Excellent surgeon and very nice man!
Had the initial meeting with Dr. Creighton for a rotator cuff tear. He was nice and answered all my questions. He gave me the option of watching and waiting vs surgery and told me about the side effects and recovery period. He also showed me a picture online of what the repair will look like. So far, everything went smooth and I am not stressed about the surgery anymore. I feel like I am in good hands and just want to get it done with.
Expeditious, informative, and caring attention
Cariing, effective and proactive. He's helllped me numerous times with my hands, wrists and shoulder. Plus, he's a fellow Hoosier! The only drawback is wait times often run long. Be prepared.
Dr Creighton is easy to talk with and he answer my questions. I would love to have him do my shoulder surgery but I am moving back home and will continue my care there. Thank you for your expertise.