Dr. Mathews graduated from Bluffton University with honors in Biology and Chemistry. He worked his way through his undergraduate studies as an orderly in the operating room at Blanchard Valley Hospital where he was first introduced to and developed an interest in orthopaedic surgery.
Dr. Mathews went on to earn his medical degree from Ohio University and completed his orthopedic surgery residency at Mercy St. Vincent Medical Center in Toledo. He is a member of the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons and the Ohio Orthopaedic Society.
Dr. Mathews graduated from Bluffton University with honors in Biology and Chemistry. He worked his way through his undergraduate studies as an orderly in the operating room at Blanchard Valley Hospital where he was first introduced to and developed an interest in orthopaedic surgery.
Dr. Mathews went on to earn his medical degree from Ohio University and completed his orthopedic surgery residency at Mercy St. Vincent Medical Center in Toledo. He is a member of the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons and the Ohio Orthopaedic Society.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Orthopaedic Institute of Ohio through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
He’s a good doc , very nice and very polite, and gentile with those needles!
(2 weeks ago)
Sep-2025
I like him, I might be dancing in a day or two. Thanks Doc. Scott Coder
(2 weeks ago)
Sep-2025
My script did not get sent to Walgreens
(2 weeks ago)
Sep-2025
Attentive, well spoken and compassionate
(1 month ago)
Sep-2025
Competent and friendly, with a professional demeanor. If you're considering joint surgery or total joint replacement, Dr. Mathews and OIO should be 1st on your list
(1 month ago)
Sep-2025
Nice guy, seems to listen to concerns and is realistic with what patients will actually do opposed to what they should do. I feel like my loved ones is being well cared for by Dr. Mathews and the whole staff at OIO. Thank you!
(1 month ago)
Aug-2025
Nice guy! Straight to the point!
(1 month ago)
Aug-2025
I love him great bedside, manor.
Makes you feel very comfortable.I trust him
(2 months ago)
Aug-2025
Was referred to Dr. Mathews for meniscus tear. Options were discussed and successful support.
(2 months ago)
Jul-2025
Set the correct expectation and was a great guy. I'm totally happy with him and his capabilities for fixing me. Thank you Dr. Mathews
"Dr. Dylan J. Mathews, D.O. is a Hancock County native, graduating from Arlington High School. Dr. Mathews graduated from Bluffton University with honors in Biology and Chemistry. He worked his way through his undergraduate studies as an orderly in the operating room at Blanchard Valley Hospital where he was first introduced to and developed an interest in orthopaedic surgery.
Dr. Mathews went on to earn his medical degree from Ohio University and completed his orthopedic surgery residency at Mercy St. Vincent Medical Center in Toledo. He is a member of the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons and the Ohio Orthopaedic Society.
Dr. Mathews provides comprehensive orthopedic care and is experienced in treating orthopedic trauma. He has broad orthopedic interests including primary shoulder, hip, and knee replacement as well as rotator cuff repair, ACL reconstruction, and general adult and pediatric fracture care.
Dr. Mathews is excited to return home and provide excellent orthopaedic care to the community. He enjoys spending time with family, hunting, fishing and is an active member of his local church. He currently resides in Findlay with his wife, Abbie."
See other doctors in Orthopaedic Institute of Ohio
He’s a good doc , very nice and very polite, and gentile with those needles!
I like him, I might be dancing in a day or two. Thanks Doc. Scott Coder
My script did not get sent to Walgreens
Attentive, well spoken and compassionate
Competent and friendly, with a professional demeanor. If you're considering joint surgery or total joint replacement, Dr. Mathews and OIO should be 1st on your list
Nice guy, seems to listen to concerns and is realistic with what patients will actually do opposed to what they should do. I feel like my loved ones is being well cared for by Dr. Mathews and the whole staff at OIO. Thank you!
Nice guy! Straight to the point!
I love him great bedside, manor. Makes you feel very comfortable.I trust him
Was referred to Dr. Mathews for meniscus tear. Options were discussed and successful support.
Set the correct expectation and was a great guy. I'm totally happy with him and his capabilities for fixing me. Thank you Dr. Mathews