David Gerstenfeld, M.D.

Island Eye Surgery Specialists

Ophthalmology

Eltingville, Sunnyside

The reviews listed below were collected independently of Island Eye Surgery Specialists through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.

I am so happy with Dr. Gerstenfeld! He is so nice, thorough and caring. Everyone who works there is very nice. Both my husband and I had appointments and were done after less than an hour.

May-2025

Excellent doctor! Very thorough, professional, and kind.

May-2025

Great experience everyone was very heloful

May-2025

Front desk and office staff are pleasant, but physician is rushed and the whole interaction including exam was less than five minutes. There was no counseling off the medication he was prescribing and when I wanted to know more about it, he did not appreciate being questioned.

May-2025

The best run office…great assistants and great Doctor…couldn’t be better

May-2025

Articulate…and clear examination …

May-2025

He is a very smart man and personally a very good person + excellent leader in surgery. I wish him well in retirement + I will miss him

May-2025

Alarming situation. Very quick app. Dr G's exam and conclusion put me at ease. Always very pleased with Dr G and his staff.

May-2025

I was having an issue that I was very worried about. Dr. Gerstenfeld treated it immediately and the issue is resolved! He is professional, compassionate, and expert. I wouldn’t trust my eyes to anyone else.

May-2025

Dr Gerstenfeld is always professional and thorough.

May-2025
Read More