David Gerstenfeld, M.D.

Island Eye Surgery Specialists

Ophthalmology

Eltingville, Sunnyside

Most recent review: 4 days ago New
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Island Eye Surgery Specialists through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.

The best ophthalmologist on the Island. Courteous, professional and to the point.

(4 days ago) Dec-2025

Best doctor ever! Had to refer a friend for an emergency last year and the doc took good care of him too!

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

Dr. Gerstenfeld is professional, respectful and thorough in examination, as well as explanation of exam. First time at the Victory Blvd location. Staff is helpful and polite. Thanks to all at Island Eye.

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

Beautiful doctor expertise in his field

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

Excellent bedside manner Excellent Surgeon . Lucky me!

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

Dr Gerstenfeld is Absolutely the best. He was very thorough, took plenty of time to go over my exam results. He will be missed dearly, but he has earned hir retirement!

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

Best Dr. sorry he is retiring. Truly losing a wonderful man. Hope he and his wife enjoy retirement together. God bless

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

fanf fantastic doctor

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

He and his father have been our eye drs since, seems like forever, and now that he is retiring will be terribly missed

(1 week ago) Dec-2025

Best practice in Staten Island

(2 weeks ago) Nov-2025
Read More