Dr. Craig S. Radnay is a board certified and fellowship trained orthopedic surgeon specializing in sports and reconstructive foot and ankle surgery as well as sports medicine and arthritic disorders of the knee. He previously served as Director and attending orthopedic surgeon at the Insall Scott Kelly Institute for Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine in New York City.
Dr. Craig S. Radnay is a board certified and fellowship trained orthopedic surgeon specializing in sports and reconstructive foot and ankle surgery as well as sports medicine and arthritic disorders of the knee. He previously served as Director and attending orthopedic surgeon at the Insall Scott Kelly Institute for Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine in New York City.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Florida Orthopaedic Institute through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
Dr. Radnay is clearly very knowledgeable and confident in his work, he was very kind. I left with some concerns and questions but overall seems like a great doctor and trustworthy.
Sep-2025
Very knowledgeable and explains things to you.
Sep-2025
Takes his time, explains well.
Sep-2025
Very attentive and thorough
Sep-2025
The wait time was atrocious, with absolutely no apologies for my time spent waiting. I was in the office for over two hours for a sprained ankle. After waiting so long for Dr. Radney, I expected more time with him. It felt like he couldn’t get out of the exam room quick enough. The office staff was also ehhh, there were so many patients in and out that it didn’t feel personal, it felt like assembly line medical treatment.
All in all, a disappointing experience.
Aug-2025
Great communication skills. That's a plus for me with a doctor. I understood everything he explained to me.
Aug-2025
Great doctor. He did a great job on my recent toe surgery.
Aug-2025
Gave me information which allowed me to select the procedure that fits my requirements.
Aug-2025
Dr Radnay has a great bedside manner, and it’s nice that he follows up surgery with a personal call to answer any questions.
Dr. Craig S. Radnay is a board certified and fellowship trained orthopedic surgeon specializing in sports and reconstructive foot and ankle surgery as well as sports medicine and arthritic disorders of the knee. He previously served as Director and attending orthopedic surgeon at the Insall Scott Kelly Institute for Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine in New York City. He was also a clinical assistant professor at NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital and Director of the Foot and Ankle service at St. Francis Hospital in Roslyn, New York.
Dr. Radnay completed his undergraduate degree at Dartmouth College and his medical degree at Columbia University’s College of Physicians and Surgeons. He completed his residency in orthopedic surgery at the New York Orthopaedic Hospital at Columbia University, where he served as chief resident. He completed a fellowship in sports medicine and knee reconstruction at the Insall Scott Kelly Institute, where he trained with the physicians of the New York Knicks and New York Yankees. He then completed a second foot and ankle surgery fellowship at Florida Orthopaedic Institute.
Dr. Radnay cares for all foot, ankle, and knee conditions. His special interests include helping treat ankle instability, painful ankle arthritis, foot and ankle fractures and trauma, flatfoot deformity, Achilles and peroneal tendon disorders, painful bunion and forefoot deformity, meniscus injuries, and primary and revision total knee replacement. Additionally, he has extensive experience with regenerative medicine treatments for various pathologies, including biologics, platelet-rich plasma, and marrow and adipose stem cells. Based on his expertise, Dr. Radnay has been invited to present at numerous national and international meetings for more than a decade. He is a member of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society, and the Orthopedic Trauma Association. He also continues to cochair an annual conference, Current Solutions in Foot & Ankle Surgery.
Dr. Radnay takes pride in caring for patients of all ages and activity levels. He believes patient education and understanding of diagnosis and all treatment options are paramount. As someone who is very active and enjoys swimming, running, biking, and traveling, he appreciates how important staying active can be for maintaining one’s overall health and wellbeing. His mission is to help patients return to activities that make them happy. He offers all his patients innovative surgical and nonsurgical treatments and helps them to understand all their available options completely. He also makes sure that they understand what to expect during their recovery so that they have a clear picture every step of the way.
See other doctors in Florida Orthopaedic Institute
Dr. Radnay is clearly very knowledgeable and confident in his work, he was very kind. I left with some concerns and questions but overall seems like a great doctor and trustworthy.
Very knowledgeable and explains things to you.
Takes his time, explains well.
Very attentive and thorough
The wait time was atrocious, with absolutely no apologies for my time spent waiting. I was in the office for over two hours for a sprained ankle. After waiting so long for Dr. Radney, I expected more time with him. It felt like he couldn’t get out of the exam room quick enough. The office staff was also ehhh, there were so many patients in and out that it didn’t feel personal, it felt like assembly line medical treatment. All in all, a disappointing experience.
Great communication skills. That's a plus for me with a doctor. I understood everything he explained to me.
Great doctor. He did a great job on my recent toe surgery.
Gave me information which allowed me to select the procedure that fits my requirements.
Dr Radnay has a great bedside manner, and it’s nice that he follows up surgery with a personal call to answer any questions.
He is awesome!