Dr. Amalia M. de Comas is a Board-Certified and Fellowship-Trained Orthopedic Surgeon specializing in adult and pediatric musculoskeletal oncology, primary and revision joint replacement surgery of the hip & knee and is also a limb salvage specialist. During her fellowship, she worked in conjunction with leading oncology experts, with a focus on treatments for orthopedic ailments.
Dr. Amalia M. de Comas is a Board-Certified and Fellowship-Trained Orthopedic Surgeon specializing in adult and pediatric musculoskeletal oncology, primary and revision joint replacement surgery of the hip & knee and is also a limb salvage specialist. During her fellowship, she worked in conjunction with leading oncology experts, with a focus on treatments for orthopedic ailments.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of The CORE Institute through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
Good service very nice
(6 days ago)
Dec-2025
Amalia did an excellent job on my knee and I’m looking forward to life with zeal again!! 🙏 thank you
(1 week ago)
Dec-2025
She did not exhibit the knowledge of the surgery that she was going to perform.
She got aggravated when she did not know which leg she was working on.
The anesthesiologist asked if I would agree to a nerve block, which I did. But his helper came in I assume she determined it wasn’t necessary. Before I left the hospital No one could explain. In recovery they put pain medicine a few times before I could go.
Dr. Decomas said it was a tiny tumor/ligation but 10 staples later, I disagree. No postoperative guidance was given other some pages that did not apply to my case.
I called and of course left a message Friday 12/-12/25 regarding showering and to date I have not received a response, it is 12/16/25 this evening. I am in excruciating pain but I can get no help, the phone system is go crazy, then leave a message for No one to call you back. I thought the VA was BAD. No this is my worst experience.
I am very disappointed in the care I have received. I will relate that back to the VA.
(1 week ago)
Dec-2025
Dr. DeComas is always very friendly and spends time answering any questions I might have. She has done both my total knee replacements and I would recommend her highly for anyone that needed that surgery.
(1 week ago)
Dec-2025
Muy buena, le doy 10 puntos.
(1 week ago)
Dec-2025
She canceled my surgery
(1 week ago)
Dec-2025
Good doc
(2 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
1st time seeing her. Very cut to the chase and answered my questions.
(2 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
Always the best with her work
(2 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
She lied to me..Said that the hardware can't be removed from my knee cuz my leg will break but if I had her $35000 knee replacement it could be removed...wtf
(2 weeks ago)
Dec-2025
Read More
Scottsdale Clinic
8952 E Desert Cove Ave Suite 113 Scottsdale, AZ 85260
Dr. Amalia M. de Comas is a Board-Certified and Fellowship-Trained Orthopedic Surgeon specializing in adult and pediatric musculoskeletal oncology, primary and revision joint replacement surgery of the hip & knee and is also a limb salvage specialist.
Before joining The CORE Institute, Dr. de Comas completed a fellowship in musculoskeletal oncology in the Department of Orthopedic Surgery at the world-renowned MD Anderson at the University of Texas. During her fellowship, she worked in conjunction with leading oncology experts, with a focus on treatments for orthopedic ailments.
Dr. de Comas completed her residency program in the Department of Orthopedic Surgery at Ochsner Healthcare System. For the duration of her residency, Dr. de Comas assisted in providing the medical coverage for athletic competitions at several Louisiana High School football teams and the University of New Orleans basketball team. She received her doctoral degree at Tulane University School of Medicine. Fluent in Spanish, Dr. de Comas served as the Medical Spanish Instructor at Tulane School of Medicine. In addition, she was the Director of Service Learning at Ozanam Inn, a student-driven minor medical clinic and tuberculosis testing facility.
Dr. de Comas earned her undergraduate degree at Lee University, where she graduated summa cum laude. Upon graduation, she and a team of physicians volunteered their medical expertise to the underprivileged communities in Honduras.
Dr. de Comas is actively involved in academic medicine, contributing as an author to several academic publications, including the Journal of Pediatric Hematology/Oncology, the Journal of Arthroplasty, and the American Journal of Orthopedics. She has lectured at various forums and academic symposiums in the medical community. Dr. de Comas is a member of numerous professional societies, including the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society, the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, the American Medical Association, the Ruth Jackson Orthopedic Society, and the Louisiana State Medical Society.
Good service very nice
Amalia did an excellent job on my knee and I’m looking forward to life with zeal again!! 🙏 thank you
She did not exhibit the knowledge of the surgery that she was going to perform. She got aggravated when she did not know which leg she was working on. The anesthesiologist asked if I would agree to a nerve block, which I did. But his helper came in I assume she determined it wasn’t necessary. Before I left the hospital No one could explain. In recovery they put pain medicine a few times before I could go. Dr. Decomas said it was a tiny tumor/ligation but 10 staples later, I disagree. No postoperative guidance was given other some pages that did not apply to my case. I called and of course left a message Friday 12/-12/25 regarding showering and to date I have not received a response, it is 12/16/25 this evening. I am in excruciating pain but I can get no help, the phone system is go crazy, then leave a message for No one to call you back. I thought the VA was BAD. No this is my worst experience. I am very disappointed in the care I have received. I will relate that back to the VA.
Dr. DeComas is always very friendly and spends time answering any questions I might have. She has done both my total knee replacements and I would recommend her highly for anyone that needed that surgery.
Muy buena, le doy 10 puntos.
She canceled my surgery
Good doc
1st time seeing her. Very cut to the chase and answered my questions.
Always the best with her work
She lied to me..Said that the hardware can't be removed from my knee cuz my leg will break but if I had her $35000 knee replacement it could be removed...wtf