Specialty > Primary Care > Indiana > Henry Community Health > Catherine Marsteller, MD

Catherine Marsteller, MD

Henry Community Health

Primary Care

New Castle, IN

Most recent review: 1 week ago Recent
5.0
133 Ratings
64 Comments

Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.

5.0
133 Ratings
64 Comments

Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.

The reviews listed below were collected independently of Henry Community Health through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.

One of the most personable and thorough PCPs I have been to. So glad I switched to her.

(1 week ago) Jun-2026

Very attentive to detail and helping to get better

(1 week ago) Jun-2026

Dr Marstellar listens and advises and isn’t in a rush to get out of the room. I really appreciate her.

(2 weeks ago) Jun-2026

Dr. Marstellar is the best doctor I have ever had! She listens, takes her tie to talk to me and doesn't rush

(2 weeks ago) Jun-2026

Caring, knowledgeable Doctor, who doesn't hesitate to do research on questions I ask. Appreciate her honesty and integrity.

(2 weeks ago) Jun-2026

Dr. Marsteller always takes time to help you with all questions and concerns. She makes you feel comfortable and the visit less stressful. Thank you.

(3 weeks ago) Jun-2026

Dr. Marcella really listens to me and I am so glad I switched to her. She is a wonderful doctor.

(1 month ago) May-2026

Best Doctor ever!!!

(1 month ago) May-2026

Very nice, listened to me. Very through in looking at my chart and getting to know me Very satisfied with Dr.Marsteller

(1 month ago) May-2026

Comparing the conversation of my other Dr. and Dr Marsteller. She seems to really care and treats her patients with kindness. She takes the time explain without rush. We need more Catherine’s in the medical field😊

(1 month ago) May-2026
Read More
See other doctors in Henry Community Health

Wil Adams, DPM

Chris Carls, DO

Bruce W. Benninger, MD, FACOG

Clay Strong, MD

Damion M. Harris, MD, FAAOS

Anjan P. Kaushik, MD, FAAOS

Thomas J. Mathews, MD, FAAOS

Lindsey R. Rolston, MD, ABOS-C, FAAOS

Kyle W. Siewert, MD, FAAOS

Mackenzie Cherry, PA-C

Wesley R. Coffman, MS, PA-C

Molly Cox, PA-C

Maddy Garreth, PA

Hillary J. Lee, MS, PA-C

Kaycie Patrick, FNP-C

Kelly Peasley, NP

Renee I. Wright, PA-C

Dana Jones, MD

Elles S. Niessen, FNP-C, MSN, BSN

Andrew M. Davisson, MD

Scott B. Taylor, MD

Kristin R. Shields, PA-C

Becky Layman, PA-C

Matthew Barrett, MD, FACS

Sara Kovacic, DO, FACOS

Andrew Ritchison, M.D.

Muhammad Afzal, MD

Megan Ash, DO

David A. Barr, MD

Gregory G. Bojrab, MD

Amy M. Carter, MD

Rebecca S. Davisson, MD

Steven Farmer, M.D.

Lisa N. Grooms, MD

David Hall, MD

Kenton S. Hilbish, MD

Saiful Kabir, M.D.

M. Lutfi Lababidi, MD

Romana Malik, MD

Steven E. Miller, MD

John Miller, MD

Roberta Jane Mueller, MD

Adam D. Rosenfeld, DO

Sara Sorrell, MD, PhD

Robert W. Stevenson, MD

Joshua Underhill, MD

Cory Thomas, D.O.

Erica R. Baumgartner, FNP-C

Amanda M. Brunck, FNP-C

Doshia Burk, FNP-BC

Mary (Liz) Butler, CPNP, MSN

Robin W. Curry, FNP-BC, LMHC

Lindi J. Davis, FNP-BC

Leah DeArmond, MSN, AGACNP-BC

Dreu Doerstler, DNP, APRN, ANP-BC

Teresa Drescher, FNP

Taylor B. Fruth, MSN, APRN, FNP-C

Billie Geise, FNP

Shelley Gough, MSN, FNP-C

Megan Knupp, MSN, CPNP-PC

Katie Lee, FNP-C

Amy D. Lovan, FNP-BC

Lindsey M. Miles, FNP-BC

Joseph Moto, FNP-C

Annie Moore, NP-C

Taylor D. Moore, NP-C

Kelsey Moore, ANP-C

Sara E. Mueller, FNP

Danielle Ogilvie, FNP-C

Ashley N. Razor, FNP-C

Juli D. Taylor, APRN-BC

Lauren Waugh, PA-C, MPAS

Lorri C. Webster, CPNP-BC, AGNP-BC

Matthew Hinshaw, BS, MSPAS, PA-C