Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.
Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Henry Community Health through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.
One of the best doctors I've ever had every time I go to see hem at their office I do not feel like cattle being pushed through a line. They actually spend time with you get to know you very well. and instead of feeling like cattle, it feels like I am visiting family instead of a doctor. I feel comfortable about telling her all the issues that I'm having they take time and go over with you all the options and diagnosis that you've had and tells you the options from there this Doctor used to work at another facility and she moved to Henry County, which is about a half hour 45 minute drive from where I live and she makes me feel so comfortable and she's such a good doctor that I drive that far to go see her every time and have no regrets about doing it. I want to thank her and her staff for taking the time out and helping me through my problems that I'm having highly recommended from me in my family because without her,I probably wouldn't be here today & thank her & staff every day
(5 days ago)
Mar-2026
Dr. Marsteller does a great job of listening and paying attention to. I appreciate her calm bedside manner.
(6 days ago)
Mar-2026
Her concern for my health was very good.
(6 days ago)
Mar-2026
Patient, knowledgeable and kind.
(6 days ago)
Mar-2026
Exceptional Physician.
(1 week ago)
Feb-2026
Very kind and understanding, 10/10 will go again
(1 week ago)
Feb-2026
I followed Dr. Marstellar from her previous office. Doesn’t that say enough?
(2 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
This was my first visit and she made me feel comfortable and truly listened and informative. Kind and understanding.
(2 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
She always listen and answers any questions I have
(2 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
Takes time to listen to all of your concerns and addresses each one. She communicates well and makes sure you know your options. East to talk to and doesn’t make you feel judged.
(3 weeks ago)
Feb-2026
Read More
New Castle Family and Internal Medicine - Northfield Park
152 Wittenbraker Ave New Castle, IN 47362
Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.
One of the best doctors I've ever had every time I go to see hem at their office I do not feel like cattle being pushed through a line. They actually spend time with you get to know you very well. and instead of feeling like cattle, it feels like I am visiting family instead of a doctor. I feel comfortable about telling her all the issues that I'm having they take time and go over with you all the options and diagnosis that you've had and tells you the options from there this Doctor used to work at another facility and she moved to Henry County, which is about a half hour 45 minute drive from where I live and she makes me feel so comfortable and she's such a good doctor that I drive that far to go see her every time and have no regrets about doing it. I want to thank her and her staff for taking the time out and helping me through my problems that I'm having highly recommended from me in my family because without her,I probably wouldn't be here today & thank her & staff every day
Dr. Marsteller does a great job of listening and paying attention to. I appreciate her calm bedside manner.
Her concern for my health was very good.
Patient, knowledgeable and kind.
Exceptional Physician.
Very kind and understanding, 10/10 will go again
I followed Dr. Marstellar from her previous office. Doesn’t that say enough?
This was my first visit and she made me feel comfortable and truly listened and informative. Kind and understanding.
She always listen and answers any questions I have
Takes time to listen to all of your concerns and addresses each one. She communicates well and makes sure you know your options. East to talk to and doesn’t make you feel judged.