Specialty > Primary Care > Indiana > Henry Community Health > Catherine Marsteller, MD

Catherine Marsteller, MD

Henry Community Health

Primary Care

New Castle, IN

Most recent review: 3 days ago New
5.0
171 Ratings
80 Comments

Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.

5.0
171 Ratings
80 Comments

Dr. Catherine Marsteller, M.D. is a primary care doctor in Henry Community Health who sees patients at New Castle Family and Internal Medicine – Northfield Park.

The reviews listed below were collected independently of Henry Community Health through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.

She is the best doctor that I've ever had she knows everything about me. She is a very compassionate doctor.

(3 days ago) Sep-2026

She is very knowledgeable, explained things, and listened. I am very pleased with Dr. Marsteller, and tell everyone how great she is.

(3 days ago) Sep-2026

I saw Dr M for the first time today, she is an active listener, did not rush our appt, offered a clear treatment plan and had incredible bedside manner. I never felt rushed, she addressed each of my concerns and answered my questions clearly She made me feel welcomed, respected and completely at ease during the visit. And the office staff was great too!

(5 days ago) Sep-2026

The doctor is very professional

(6 days ago) Sep-2026

She address more then just a single issue as about every other doctor in the past has naking health issues go untreated. She also told me info about a healrh issue that multiple doctors have see in test the done but not a one said a word about it

(1 week ago) Sep-2026

The visit was great I look forward to seeing her as my primary caregiver thank you for all your help you are awesome

(3 weeks ago) Sep-2026

always so nice! makes me feel comfortable

(3 weeks ago) Sep-2026

She’s a very good listener & cares about her patients. She’s helping me restore faith in the medical profession by simply listening & doing her own research about my neurological condition. So thankful I found her.

(3 weeks ago) Sep-2026

Dr. Marsteller is THE BEST doctor! She takes all the time with her patients that they need. She is thoughtful, compassionate, and very thorough with her care.

(1 month ago) Aug-2026

I am so happy to have found Catherine. She is very knowledgeable and helpful. She always takes time to ask questions and listen. I never feel rushed. She is caring and very personable. Glad to have her as my Dr.

(1 month ago) Aug-2026
See other doctors in Henry Community Health

Wil Adams, DPM

Chris Carls, DO

Bruce W. Benninger, MD, FACOG

Clay Strong, MD

Damion M. Harris, MD, FAAOS

Anjan P. Kaushik, MD, FAAOS

Thomas J. Mathews, MD, FAAOS

Lindsey R. Rolston, MD, ABOS-C, FAAOS

Kyle W. Siewert, MD, FAAOS

Mackenzie Cherry, PA-C

Wesley R. Coffman, MS, PA-C

Molly Cox, PA-C

Maddy Garreth, PA

Hillary J. Lee, MS, PA-C

Kaycie Patrick, FNP-C

Kelly Peasley, NP

Renee I. Wright, PA-C

Dana Jones, MD

Elles S. Niessen, FNP-C, MSN, BSN

Andrew M. Davisson, MD

Scott B. Taylor, MD

Kristin R. Shields, PA-C

Becky Layman, PA-C

Matthew Barrett, MD, FACS

Sara Kovacic, DO, FACOS

Andrew Ritchison, M.D.

Muhammad Afzal, MD

Megan Ash, DO

David A. Barr, MD

Gregory G. Bojrab, MD

Amy M. Carter, MD

Rebecca S. Davisson, MD

Steven Farmer, M.D.

Lisa N. Grooms, MD

David Hall, MD

Kenton S. Hilbish, MD

Saiful Kabir, M.D.

M. Lutfi Lababidi, MD

Romana Malik, MD

Steven E. Miller, MD

John Miller, MD

Roberta Jane Mueller, MD

Adam D. Rosenfeld, DO

Sara Sorrell, MD, PhD

Robert W. Stevenson, MD

Joshua Underhill, MD

Cory Thomas, D.O.

Erica R. Baumgartner, FNP-C

Amanda M. Brunck, FNP-C

Doshia Burk, FNP-BC

Mary (Liz) Butler, CPNP, MSN

Robin W. Curry, FNP-BC, LMHC

Lindi J. Davis, FNP-BC

Leah DeArmond, MSN, AGACNP-BC

Dreu Doerstler, DNP, APRN, ANP-BC

Teresa Drescher, FNP

Taylor B. Fruth, MSN, APRN, FNP-C

Billie Geise, FNP

Shelley Gough, MSN, FNP-C

Megan Knupp, MSN, CPNP-PC

Katie Lee, FNP-C

Amy D. Lovan, FNP-BC

Lindsey M. Miles, FNP-BC

Joseph Moto, FNP-C

Annie Moore, NP-C

Taylor D. Moore, NP-C

Kelsey Moore, ANP-C

Sara E. Mueller, FNP

Danielle Ogilvie, FNP-C

Ashley N. Razor, FNP-C

Juli D. Taylor, APRN-BC

Lauren Waugh, PA-C, MPAS

Lorri C. Webster, CPNP-BC, AGNP-BC

Matthew Hinshaw, BS, MSPAS, PA-C

Mark Reedy, M.D.

Kaden B. Jordan, MD

Kalie Bales, MSN, FNP-C

Marja McLaughlin, M.D.

Amber Burns, NP

Lisa Oakley, NP