Specialty > Primary Care > Indiana > Henry Community Health > Catherine Marsteller, MD

Catherine Marsteller, MD

Henry Community Health

Primary Care

New Castle, IN

Most recent review: 5 days ago New
The reviews listed below were collected independently of Henry Community Health through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.

Dr Marsteller is an outstanding physician. She is kind and cares about her patients.

(5 days ago) Jan-2026

Really made me comfortable talking to her

(1 week ago) Jan-2026

My first visit was very thorough!

(2 weeks ago) Jan-2026

Always willing to listen anytime to anything you need to talk about and stays on top of everything when you have issues going on until they are taken care of very Hands-On very compassionate and so sweet

(1 month ago) Dec-2025

I had a very good first visit with her. I think she knows about some of the natural supplements I take, and that is good.

(1 month ago) Dec-2025

As a woman I felt very very comfortable. She was able to provide me answers for any questions I had and soothed my anxiety nicely ❤️ Very nice and i’m glad she’s my doctor :)

(1 month ago) Dec-2025

Excelente 👌

(1 month ago) Dec-2025

Excellent communications skills, she explains everything in terms you understand, exceptionally thorough in listening and figuring out your problems. I’ve had my fair share of disappointing doctors but marsteller is fantastic!

(1 month ago) Dec-2025

She actually listens to her patients and cares about them

(2 months ago) Nov-2025

Dr. Marstellar has been my doctor for three years. There is a reason I forgo the medical discounts that I get from my wife’s insurance at Meridian to still see her. She is an excellent doctor. Very easy to communicate with and goes out of her way to understand any issues I may have.

(2 months ago) Nov-2025
Read More
See other doctors in Henry Community Health

Wil Adams, DPM

Chris Carls, DO

Romel Antolin, MD

Bruce W. Benninger, MD, FACOG

Clay Strong, MD

Damion M. Harris, MD, FAAOS

Anjan P. Kaushik, MD, FAAOS

Thomas J. Mathews, MD, FAAOS

Lindsey R. Rolston, MD, ABOS-C, FAAOS

Kyle W. Siewert, MD, FAAOS

Mackenzie Cherry, PA-C

Wesley R. Coffman, MS, PA-C

Molly Cox, PA-C

Maddy Garreth, PA

Hillary J. Lee, MS, PA-C

Kaycie Patrick, FNP-C

Kelly Peasley, NP

Renee I. Wright, PA-C

Dana Jones, MD

Chrissy Honig, CNM

Elles S. Niessen, FNP-C, MSN, BSN

Andrew M. Davisson, MD

Scott B. Taylor, MD

Kristin R. Shields, PA-C

Becky Layman, PA-C

Matthew Barrett, MD, FACS

Sara Kovacic, DO, FACOS

Andrew Ritchison, M.D.

Muhammad Afzal, MD

Nabin Agrawal, MD

Megan Ash, DO

David A. Barr, MD

Gregory G. Bojrab, MD

Amy M. Carter, MD

Rebecca S. Davisson, MD

Steven Farmer, M.D.

Lisa N. Grooms, MD

David Hall, MD

Kenton S. Hilbish, MD

Saiful Kabir, M.D.

M. Lutfi Lababidi, MD

Lynn M. Losby, MD, DABFM

Romana Malik, MD

Steven E. Miller, MD, CWS

John Miller, MD

Roberta Jane Mueller, MD

Adam D. Rosenfeld, DO

Sara Sorrell, MD, PhD

Robert W. Stevenson, MD

Joshua Underhill, MD

Cory Thomas, D.O.

Erica R. Baumgartner, FNP-C

Amanda M. Brunck, FNP-C

Doshia Burk, FNP-BC

Mary (Liz) Butler, CPNP, MSN

Robin W. Curry, FNP-BC, LMHC

Lindi J. Davis, FNP-BC

Leah DeArmond, MSN, AGACNP-BC

Dreu Doerstler, DNP, APRN, ANP-BC

Teresa Drescher, FNP

Taylor B. Fruth, MSN, APRN, FNP-C

Billie Geise, FNP

Shelley Gough, MSN, FNP-C

Megan Knupp, MSN, CPNP-PC

Katie Lee, FNP-C

Amy D. Lovan, FNP-BC

Lindsey M. Miles, FNP-BC

Joseph Moto, FNP-C

Annie Moore, NP-C

Taylor D. Moore, NP-C

Kelsey Moore, ANP-C

Sara E. Mueller, FNP

Danielle Ogilvie, FNP-C

Ashley N. Razor, FNP-C

Juli D. Taylor, APRN-BC

Lauren Waugh, PA-C, MPAS

Lorri C. Webster, CPNP-BC, AGNP-BC