Amy M. Carter, MD

Henry Community Health

Primary Care, Family Medicine

New Castle, IN

Most recent review: 4 days ago New
4.9
101 Ratings
39 Comments

"I am a Family Medicine physician with over 25 years experience. I focus on educating and empowering patients to do what they can to improve their health and prolong their functional status or health span. I am a certified Functional Medicine practitioner which means that I try to find the root cause of illness rather than just prescribing treatment. I expect my patients to explore restorative avenues to improve their health in partnership with me. I enjoy providing care for all ages. I am adventurous and enjoy traveling, camping, and learning new skills."

4.9
101 Ratings
39 Comments

"I am a Family Medicine physician with over 25 years experience. I focus on educating and empowering patients to do what they can to improve their health and prolong their functional status or health span. I am a certified Functional Medicine practitioner which means that I try to find the root cause of illness rather than just prescribing treatment. I expect my patients to explore restorative avenues to improve their health in partnership with me. I enjoy providing care for all ages. I am adventurous and enjoy traveling, camping, and learning new skills."

The reviews listed below were collected independently of Henry Community Health through rater8. Each review represents an authentic and verified patient experience.

Best Doctor I have ever been to!! She is Great !!

(4 days ago) Sep-2026

Very helpful and compassionate

(4 days ago) Sep-2026

I had to wait over a hour to see the doctor. They said it was because of the lady checking me in

(2 weeks ago) Aug-2026

I didn’t even have an appointment.Dr Carter got me in next morning because she knew that I was sick! She is a wonderful doctor!!

(3 weeks ago) Aug-2026

Dr. Carter is very personable and thorough. She answered all our questions in a professional manner. (We had a lot of them.) She ran needed tests immediately and completed the forms we needed during that visit. Awesome!

(1 month ago) Jul-2026

Amazing and listens to her patients

(1 month ago) Jul-2026

Dr. Carter really listens to what I have to say and respects my opinions about and experiences with my own body. I am thankful to have her as my doctor.

(1 month ago) Jul-2026

She is a very caring and well-rounded doctor who always has our best interests at heart. Privileged to be one of her patients!

(1 month ago) Jul-2026

She is an amazing doctor who thinks outside of the box. It’s a shame such great doctors are controlled by the medical insurance machine.

(2 months ago) Jul-2026

Never had a doctor who was so thorough. Very detailed and really interested in your health.

(2 months ago) Jul-2026
Read More
See other doctors in Henry Community Health

Wil Adams, DPM

Chris Carls, DO

Bruce W. Benninger, MD, FACOG

Clay Strong, MD

Damion M. Harris, MD, FAAOS

Anjan P. Kaushik, MD, FAAOS

Thomas J. Mathews, MD, FAAOS

Lindsey R. Rolston, MD, ABOS-C, FAAOS

Kyle W. Siewert, MD, FAAOS

Mackenzie Cherry, PA-C

Wesley R. Coffman, MS, PA-C

Molly Cox, PA-C

Maddy Garreth, PA

Hillary J. Lee, MS, PA-C

Kaycie Patrick, FNP-C

Kelly Peasley, NP

Renee I. Wright, PA-C

Dana Jones, MD

Elles S. Niessen, FNP-C, MSN, BSN

Andrew M. Davisson, MD

Scott B. Taylor, MD

Kristin R. Shields, PA-C

Becky Layman, PA-C

Matthew Barrett, MD, FACS

Sara Kovacic, DO, FACOS

Andrew Ritchison, M.D.

Muhammad Afzal, MD

Megan Ash, DO

David A. Barr, MD

Gregory G. Bojrab, MD

Rebecca S. Davisson, MD

Steven Farmer, M.D.

Lisa N. Grooms, MD

David Hall, MD

Kenton S. Hilbish, MD

Saiful Kabir, M.D.

M. Lutfi Lababidi, MD

Romana Malik, MD

Catherine Marsteller, MD

Steven E. Miller, MD

John Miller, MD

Roberta Jane Mueller, MD

Adam D. Rosenfeld, DO

Sara Sorrell, MD, PhD

Robert W. Stevenson, MD

Joshua Underhill, MD

Cory Thomas, D.O.

Erica R. Baumgartner, FNP-C

Amanda M. Brunck, FNP-C

Doshia Burk, FNP-BC

Mary (Liz) Butler, CPNP, MSN

Robin W. Curry, FNP-BC, LMHC

Lindi J. Davis, FNP-BC

Leah DeArmond, MSN, AGACNP-BC

Dreu Doerstler, DNP, APRN, ANP-BC

Teresa Drescher, FNP

Taylor B. Fruth, MSN, APRN, FNP-C

Billie Geise, FNP

Shelley Gough, MSN, FNP-C

Megan Knupp, MSN, CPNP-PC

Katie Lee, FNP-C

Amy D. Lovan, FNP-BC

Lindsey M. Miles, FNP-BC

Joseph Moto, FNP-C

Annie Moore, NP-C

Taylor D. Moore, NP-C

Kelsey Moore, ANP-C

Sara E. Mueller, FNP

Danielle Ogilvie, FNP-C

Ashley N. Razor, FNP-C

Juli D. Taylor, APRN-BC

Lauren Waugh, PA-C, MPAS

Lorri C. Webster, CPNP-BC, AGNP-BC

Matthew Hinshaw, BS, MSPAS, PA-C

Mark Reedy, M.D.

Kaden B. Jordan, MD